Overstocking New World Cichlids???

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
the one i had was also evil , when 3" it dominated the other mbunas , i took it out and put it with 7-8" tinfoil barbs thinking it will stay ok or would get eaten by the barbs but it dominated them too
Mine actually was submissive to a red zebra male, and was his head enforcer. This lasted a few years until I did a rescape, at which point the auratus decided he had enough of being second in line. His reign only lasted a few months until a parasitic infection killed them all, but he was brutal and injured a lot of my cichlids. Beautiful fish in dominant coloration though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ..puSkar..
Comparing dogs with fish is not worthy imo. u can train a Pitbull to be mild mannered and also a Labrador to be aggressive but you cannot train a dovii to be less aggressive or a goldfish to be super aggressive
Does comparing my dog to a puffer fish count? Fat, slow (fast when necessary), smart but stupid at the same time, and eats everything.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tunabish
Does comparing my dog to a puffer fish count? Fat, slow (fast when necessary), smart but stupid at the same time, and eats everything.
u can compare anything with anyone , but biologically a dog's brain is way more complex and advanced than a fish's so their way of thought processing and acting on it is way different.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Deadeye
u can compare anything with anyone , but biologically a dog's brain is way more complex and advanced than a fish's so their way of thought processing and acting on it is way different.
I agree there, mine is more out of comedy.
I do think it is safe to compare to get certain ideas across about behavior etc.
 
DMD123 DMD123 was able to keep a good amount of amphs together in a 300 for a while, but he had just commented that the dominant one died, and it all fell apart after that.
I had 4 amphs in my 300 and it was as perfect as perfect could be because the dominate peace keeper was calm and really did not have to chase down or hurt anyone to keep the peace. He injured himself severely on a piece of driftwood and passed. Then the next biggest midas who likely would have been the same way has a swim bladder issue and cant run the tank so he will be euthanized. The other two are ruining a very calm tank.

This group all grew up together and they had it all figured out but then the loss of the head fish and it all went to hell. Sometimes its a delicate balance in a situation like this.
 
Never overstock your tank! You might be able to get away with it for a little while but after a few months you will eventually run into a problem or 2. Overstocking only adds more waste to the tank and more strain on the filters. You WILL need to do huge water changes more often than with an appropriately stocked tank.

To reduce aggression only stock compatible species, keep the water temps on the cooler end of the spectrum (when the water temp is near breeding temp cichlids always become more aggressive), and it’s important to have appropriate sized territories and retreats for your fish.
 
tbh every cichlid tank has its own "culture" which all depends on who the dominant fish is. For a while, the dominant fish in my cichlid tank was a shy fire mouth, so naturally the other fish in the tank hid from me a lot and didn't fight. However, now my fish tank is in a "revolution" so we'll see how that goes.
 
u can compare anything with anyone , but biologically a dog's brain is way more complex and advanced than a fish's so their way of thought processing and acting on it is way different.

You're also comparing creatures from different environments, and domesticated dogs are a genetic creation from humans. Fish for the most part are the real deal. Humans tend to call anything they can't control less intelligentl...domesticated animals were made for a reason, either food, protection, or companionship.

Killer whales, whales, elephants, dolphins have structurally equal/superior brain structure to humans...now what? You can toss in most primates too...these arguments were made decades ago by scientists who called everything 'instinct' they didn't understand. Compare the nature shows out now with old clips from say the 70s and you'll see a world of difference. Its a conceit of humans that anything resembling our structure is 'best'', intelligent or superior....but at the end of the day we're important only to our species. We dress it up with culture and tech...dominant yes, but we have hands! Not even a pimple on the universes ass.

Hell, octopus can play chess. And the oceans are still 70 percent unexplored with new species being discovered. Scientists used to swear the earth was flat, and that the sun rotated around the earth. If the dinosaurs weren't decimated millions of years ago I wonder if reptiles would be the dominant specie now instead of humans.

What all this has to do with overstocking NW cichlids? Hell if I know.
 
Last edited:
You're also comparing creatures from different environments, and domesticated dogs are a genetic creation from humans. Fish for the most part are the real deal. Humans tend to call anything they can't control less intelligentl...domesticated animals were made for a reason, either food, protection, or companionship.

Killer whales, whales, elephants, dolphins have structurally equal/superior brain structure to humans...now what? You can toss in most primates too...these arguments were made decades ago by scientists who called everything 'instinct' they didn't understand. Compare the nature shows out now with old clips from say the 70s and you'll see a world of difference. Its a conceit of humans that anything resembling our structure is 'best'', intelligent or superior....but at the end of the day we're important only to our species. We dress it up with culture and tech...dominant yes, but we have hands! Not even a pimple on the universes ass.

Hell, octopus can play chess. And the oceans are still 70 percent unexplored with new species being discovered. Scientists used to swear the earth was flat, and that the sun rotated around the earth. If the dinosaurs weren't decimated millions of years ago I wonder if reptiles would be the dominant specie now instead of humans.

What all this has to do with overstocking NW cichlids? Hell if I know.
whales, dolphins , killer whales all belong to class mammals , and not superclass Pisces ( class chondrichthyes -mainly saltwater and class osteichtyes - mainly freshwater) so yes they are more comparable to humans than if you compare a pitbull (mammal) with a dovii ( pisces) thus makes no sense compairing them to the fish we keep in the aquarium. primates and elephants also belong to mammals .
if you go through the thread what I'm trying to convey is that you can train an animal but cannot train a fish to be a certain way .
if an octopus can play chess does this prove that they are more advanced than humans ? had that been the case they would be keeping humans as pets today.
I dont know of any such species that has a more complex pattern of thinking than a human. there may be animals with a more comples or larger brain structure but it does not mean that theier way of thinking is more complex. we can smile even tho we feel like crying . we smile at people even tho they are annoying and you want to wack them on the face, can an elephant , octopus, killer whale do that?
people who said the earth was flat were more of the greek-roman astrologers , there is nothing scientific in mere assumptions. makes no sense calling such people scientists
. Its a conceit of humans that anything resembling our structure is 'best'', intelligent or superior....but at the end of the day we're important only to our species

i may not know much but I dont think that humans are important only to humans. had humans not been important to other species , many species that we still see sround would not be here. if you are considering the ecological part of food shelter etc, then the lion is also not important .
btw what do you mean by " resembling our structure " ??
And the oceans are still 70 percent unexplored with new species being discovered. Scientists used to swear the earth was flat, and that the sun rotated around the earth. If the dinosaurs weren't decimated millions of years ago I wonder if reptiles would be the dominant specie now instead of humans.
so what ? youre hoping that out of the 70% unexplored oceans some xyz species would emerge that would be more superior than humans? and had dinosaurs not been extint we would not have been here on the MFK site . btw even then would humans have a more complex brain if you see evolution . As of now humans are more complex than anything else. and it seems impossible that anything superior would emerge before a mass extinction.
What all this has to do with overstocking NW cichlids? Hell if I know
go through the whole thread you'll get your answer.
You're also comparing creatures from different environments
suggest you better go through the full thread . I am telling people not to compare

Not being rude but your argument dint make sense to me , looks like you wrote it for fun .
what say Deadeye Deadeye
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com