pH 3.85 (yikes!) and fish are happy...

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

BrookKeeper

Plecostomus
MFK Member
Jul 26, 2015
371
125
61
Shenandoah Valley, VA
I have a 37 gallon (30" x 12" x 23") fish PFS substrate, heavily planted, and three angels. All three were added at different times, I want to say around 12-24 months ago. At one point I had 4, but one was pretty stressed due to aggression, and one afternoon I found him between the heater and the glass, and he had burned himself pretty badly, and I put him down. Other than that, I have had no health issues, and the other three get along well enough.

I am the type that once my tanks are up and running, I provide test until I have a routine, and then I tend to put my kit away and maintain that routine. I try to keep my angels on the acidic side, and I use RO water for water always. I add calcium carbonate to most of my tanks and maintain a pH of about 7.25-7.5. The angels hardly ever get water changes (every couple of months) and their nitrates never leave 15-20 ppm (I do check that from time to time). I recently have started playing with different testing equipment and methods, and it has come to my attention that my pH is pretty consistent in the angel tank... @ 3.85! I have been hesitant to change anything too quickly, and have just spent the last couple of weeks verifying that this is a stable condition.

I have been thinking about adding some loaches, maybe a couple of kuhlis, but definitely need something to occupy the bottom of the tank. I am going to have to adjust the pH before I add anything in good conscience. I will add a tiny bit of calcium carbonate aggregate tonight and see where it gets me over the next few day.

Any thoughts or advice?
 
I added about 50 grams of calcite to the tank, pH is up to 4.3 and slowly rising. While the initial jump was pretty quick from 3.8-4.15, the graph shown is over 75 minutes, and you can see that the shift is slow and steady after that initial jump. Hang on, angels! Curious to see where the pH settles out over the next couple of days.
2015-09-06 11.54.35.jpg
 
Wow, are you sure that's accurate?

That's about the equivalent pH of Sprite soda!
 
2015-09-06 16.48.59.jpg Yes, the meter is both accurate and precise... Freshly calibrated at in buffer solutions of pH 4.00 and 7.00, reads those points dead on. I have been tracking pH in all four of my tanks, the other three range between 6.75 and 7.5 and change appropriately in response to watch changes with RO water. I use calcite in my other three tanks to buffer the pH, so following water changes there is a slight dip, then the pH comes back up as the calcite dissolves and buffers the carbonic acid. I had not used calcite in my angel tank, as the prefer soft and (slightly) acidic conditions, and as I said in the opening post, I generally take a 'set it and forget it' attitude once I get an aquarium maintenance schedule established. I don't usually test unless something seems off. I have started playing with new technology, and that is the only reason I figured out the angels were so low. They are as healthy and happy as can be!

Update several hours after calcite addition: current pH is steady at 4.64.
 
While it doesn't exactly confirm the accuracy of the meter, the API test also does not refute the meter...
2015-09-07 15.28.19.jpg
This graph represents nearly 24 hours of pH monitoring, currently reading 4.9 and gradually climbing still... y-axis ranges from 4.7-4.95
2015-09-07 15.33.38.jpg
 
2015-09-08 09.09.11.jpg
So... my second calcite drop, approximately the same size as my first, turned into a bit of an oopsie daisy. Definitely did not mean to jump the pH from 4.8 to 6.8 that quickly (x-axis covers 38 hours of data collection...) Yea, yea... pH is a log scale, I am aware, and I should have thought to reduce the calcite for the second addition by a log value... BUT! The fishies are still acting the same, sooooo... oh well? se la vie?

I guess now that I have a *normal* pH, it is time to run to the LFS for some new additions..........

oh wait, still haven't decided what to add...

guess I could just monitor the water quality/fish health for a couple days while I think on it.
 
Cool read, you are a great addition to mfk, this info will prove very valuable to some people on here.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com