plecos and rays

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

davo

Aimara
MFK Member
Jan 9, 2006
17,544
43
132
England
unfortunately i do not own a ray at the moment but this definately applies. peoples are saying either, plecos with rays- don't do it, or can be done with care.

i have since decided i would never attempt to keep a pleco with a ray, just 'cause it isn't anywhere near worth the risk. this is because:

went home this weekend, and i keep a freshwater asian sole, obv different to a ray, but for this purpose the same principle applies. Basically its been kept together with some plecs for a few months. on saturday i realised it looked stressed, and its skin didnt seem as vibrant. on sunday i stayed up and watched in the dark and basically one pleco was chasing it around. by morning it had a slight white patch, where the slime coat and maybe some scales were completely missing. i then put it in a quarentine tank, which may end up its permanent home as it is big enough for it. it went into what i believe to be its equivelent of a death curl. for those who are interested, it basically arches the front (head) and the back of it to make a U-shape, so a bit different to a ray, and was extremely stiff. it is now however fine, and the white patch is smaller already and its back to burying itself in the sand, and just ate something. hes also more active than hes ever bean searching for food etc.

so to recap, plecos do like to suck on the slime coat of any fish, and when you put a great big surface area such as a ray or a sole, chances are it may take a while, and may graze by accident, but it is almost inevitable. once it has a taste it will NOT stop, and you are doomed unless you seperate them. i know that there will be some people that will say that it can be done, but imo, it would be stupid to try it in the first place. this particular pleco was a sailfin L083, and there are 2 of this sp. in the community tank. however it was one that got the taste and then wouldn't stop. i do hope this will put off people that are thinking of it, 'cause i imagine most people would not want to lose their ray.

soley.JPG
 
im always on the look out for my pleco sucking the slime off my ray...

first sign of slim tasting and my pleco is gonna be taken out, been 3 months and everythings fine thus far!
 
I think it is a touch and go situation when it comes to plecos and fish with a big surface area. I had a pleco in with my rays for a couple months and them I noticed it bothering my marbled pim, so I took it out. But it never touched the rays.

I also had an instince with a sail fine pleco that took out 3 9in through 12in african cichlids during the night and killed them. I have also had a pleco go after smaller fish and try and catch em.

I have seen it succesfully done though. rvrrays has a 12in pleco in with his breeding pair of motoros and he hasn't had any problems that I know of with it.

I think it just depends on the pleco, but you should still keep and eye on it.

Hope your fish comes though.
 
yea cheers it seems fine now. caught it before it got to bad- bit by chance cause im not home all the time. for people who do keep rays and plecos together, can i ask- what species?
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com