Maybe They just didn't like the change?
What did you use to coat it? Things like concrete and/or grout will change pH if not treated first.
Also,expanded polystyrene (styrofoam) is a proven
endocrine disruptor (Source
1,
2,
3, 4). This doesn't necessarily show up immediately, instead in later generations, as it has more effect during certain life stages (
birth control is a controlled endocrine disruptor). This however, this could also be a possibility . Unless you're using a flow-through system, constantly flushing the chemicals out, the leachates could build up, especially if water changes aren't done frequently. If using XPS, seal it
completely, so that water contact is minimal to non-existant.
Take that info as you choose; obviously numerous people still use it with no
visual effects (not a great defense for it though).