Problem With Wood Clouding Water Up!

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Bluegill

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Mar 24, 2007
200
0
0
Connecticut
I found 2 peices of cedar wood branches in my grandmothers basement and I put them in my fish tank and it made the water yellow. Take them out or well the filter turn the water back to it's normal color?
 
Did you rinse them or soak them or do anything to prepare them for a fish tank? If not, then I would definitely take them out as soon as possible to prevent any possible harm to the fish.
 
i agree with smpage, unless it was properly soaked you don't kno what they are releasing into your water...
 
I doub't it's anything more than normal tanins leaching out of the wood...especially with a sappy wood like cedar. Your filters won't have any real effect on the color. Remove the wood...switch to another type of seasoned driftwood and do several large water changes to return the tank to normal.
 
I would not use cedar, as it has oils and acids in it that are not so healthy for your aquarium. Also, it will rot very quickly since it is not a dense wood.
 
can't just put any wood in your tank as some do have chemicals that can kill your fish.

other than that, if you're sure the wood is safe for fish, the color is just tanin that should clear up... but you should also pre-soak the wood.
 
I thoroughly rinsed both pecies off in the bath tub. As we speak the yellow water in my bedroom 55 gallon tank has cleared up but my crawdad is missing and the bass didn't eat him maybe the cat got him. My 30 gallon tank still has a yellow tint to it.
 
Cedar and pine are two things I've been told to particularly avoid.

Oak is supposed to be good and tends not to be too rare, depending where you live of course :)

Very old oak tress often have dead wood somewhere on them so you can go out after a storm and find a few bits that have blown off. I've only used in terraria in the past but it is something I've heard used by other people in aquaria.

I posted this link onto another thread only a few minutes ago, it shows a product I have used which is a pre soaked 'marsh' root which leaches no tannins into the water; well, not the bit I had anyway.

http://www.seapets.co.uk/product-details/stkcode/956694/master/956690.html
 
If it is cedar, get rid of it. aropal is right in saying both cedar and pine are something to avoid. Plecos don't last long with it in particular.
 
natural wood take a long time for all the tannings to leech out.ive tried and gave up,it took to long for me.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com