Profitable cichlids ?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

JF Sirois

Jack Dempsey
MFK Member
Nov 13, 2015
235
79
36
26
Is there any big cichlids( over 10inches) that can get you some money by breeding a pair of them ? Not to make huge profit, but to help paying the cost of this expensive hobby
 
Is there any big cichlids( over 10inches) that can get you some money by breeding a pair of them ? Not to make huge profit, but to help paying the cost of this expensive hobby

Not 10 inches, but get yourself a pair of rare colour morph angelfish (scalare) or discus; take care of them and the fry, and you'll more than recoup your costs, especially on discus.
 
Not 10 inches, but get yourself a pair of rare colour morph angelfish (scalare) or discus; take care of them and the fry, and you'll more than recoup your costs, especially on discus.
something like festae, would it make a bit of money ? i really dont see them that often
 
something like festae, would it make a bit of money ? i really dont see them that often

Yup, the only other thing to consider is the market; once you successfully rear fry, you'll literally have hundreds, which can quickly overwhelm local lfs who then subsequently pay you less value.

Can always ship out though or deliver further afield. I know festae are rarer where I am, but it might be different for you; if I were you I'd scout around the local lfs and ask them what is rare where you are, and if they'd pay you for fry etc
 
Yup, the only other thing to consider is the market; once you successfully rear fry, you'll literally have hundreds, which can quickly overwhelm local lfs who then subsequently pay you less value.

Can always ship out though or deliver further afield. I know festae are rarer where I am, but it might be different for you; if I were you I'd scout around the local lfs and ask them what is rare where you are, and if they'd pay you for fry etc
yeah its pretty rare where im at(canada) i think it would be pretty fun to try that !!
 
I like idea, but they're pretty bloat prone early on. I made money selling guppies, and cichlid fry as food haha. You can charge more if they're well taken care of at a small size. My customers were stoked on the idea of disease free live food, I ended up getting 50 cents a piece... adds up quick with live bearers and cichlids shooting out babies all the time
 
  • Like
Reactions: JF Sirois
people ask this question often enough and unless youre ready to open a mini shop and breed several kinds of cichlids and be willing to ship... you wont make much money.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Buphy
Unless you have something that is extremely rare to have then making money will not translate into making a profit. Si I would say just enough the hobby.
 
Making a profit with a single species is not easy to do. Some of it's a moving target that follows the latest hot fish. What's hot now could lose interest in 6 months or a year. Some fish that are less common, like festae or other larger, more aggressive fish, also have a limited market, which is part of the reason they're less common-- you might do ok with some of these if there's local interest, but before long you exhaust most of that market. So rarity doesn't guarantee a market opportunity. You're not going to move the hundreds or thousands of fry some large, aggressive new world cichlids can produce.

There's always selling online, which has it's own set of challenges. Local or regional, like in a cichlid association, and it all depends on what you have, again some fish will have a limited market. Going to aquabid or ebay and now you're competition includes experienced sellers with an established reputation, you might find a niche there if you stick with it and have the right species-- or not so much.

The latest hot new fish can be profitable for a while, until everyone else and their dog is also breeding and selling them and the price goes down. Some fish do have staying power and can make some money for a successful hobby breeder, angels and discus already mentioned, Cyphotilapia, especially Zaire gibberossa (but these are harem breeders), also some African cichlids that have a niche but it's a steady niche (tropheus, for example).

Beyond that you can pick a fish you like that has staying power and more than a small niche market. You won't make a killing but probably always be able to sell some, nice severum species, oscars, some eartheater types, for example.
 
Last edited:
MonsterFishKeepers.com