depends on your definition of being "fine in freshwater" will they live past the warranty given by the store? yes. will they live longer than a few weeks? yes, perhaps even months if they have hard water with a high ph(like BW only w/out the salt and minerals) will they live their full life span? no, not even close. surfacing is vital to the crabs. they are best kept in a paludarium.mxmike;1506136; said:I bought a red claw crab, being told by the pet shop owner that he'd be fine in freshwater, and that they like to get out of the water sometimes, but its not necessary. Can anyone tell me if this is true? Is surfacing vital to the survival of this crab??? And it's ok with the water, I already have a bw tank.