Red in black water

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Hybridfish7

Bronze Tier VIP
MFK Member
Dec 4, 2017
2,901
2,842
739
So I've recently heard of the reasoning behind bright red fish existing, and that being for the ability to be seen by potential mates in tanned/dark water. However, I have recently taken an interest in redbreast sunfish. The ones in the lake I fish, being a pretty clear and rocky lake, are pretty pale and I never see the trademark red breast in them. Either that or I'm fishing the wrong parts of the lake, I'm sure there's a swamp or blackwater inlet somewhere around there. That leads us to the purpose of this thread- from what I can see, redbreasts seem to be brighter when living in back/blackwater creeks, I'm assuming this is tied to the red for attraction thing, and by that logic, theoretically if I were to catch and keep one, I should keep it in a blackwater tank?
 
Fish may display more prominent colour in darker water yes, remember red is an incredibly common colour in nature and is often used for displaying danger or potential strength. Would be interesting to compare their colours in Blackwater vs water with no tannins.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com