Replacing 1 Panel of an 8ft long Acrylic Tank?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Mastiffman

Gambusia
MFK Member
Nov 2, 2010
662
5
18
MI.
tropheusandmore.com
I had come accross a larger tank that has some crazing on the fronty panel as the tank is 30" high and is constructed with .5" Acrylic. There are some longer Lines, about -"10" long running horizontally towards the middle bottom of the tank in that front panel.

Is this something that anyone has ever tried before? I don't see why it wouldn't be done and replaced with .625" or even a piece of .75" Acrylic. As long as the current sheet is removed delcately and the edges of the tanks panels are smoothed completely flat as needed, I don't see why it couldn't be done.

Your Realistic Thoughts?
 
If I use a Long Straight edge, why wouldn't the acrylic edges be straight? I"m not going to sand it by hand... The acrylic Supplier should be able to cut it to specs. The Sides will be routered in conjunction with a straight edge...

One other thought is to cut the panel out leaving about a .75" frame of the old pane so that I can use that to weld the new pane to on the inside of that .75" lip all of the way around... Then add corner supports on the inside as well.
 
I wonder if it would be worth it - you would still have three sides built out of .5" acrylic, which is a little on the thin side for a 30" tall tank. Definitely doable, but would it be worthwhile once you consider costs, labor, and potential problems? Maybe if the tank was free and you can do the work yourself, but otherwise I don't think so...
 
Oh I plan on doing the work myself..... There's no other way. If I can learn Plumbing, Electrical, Rough and Finish carpetry, PC hardware and Software Troubleshooting as well as learning the basic ins and outs of Genetics on my own, I should be able to handle a little plastic welding.... No?

Look at like this. If water pressure is solely based off of "depth of the water"... And that pressure will have more leverage on longer run of acrylic (i.e. 8ft x 30" high) to put enough stress to cause crazing, then the sides will be fine being that they are only 24" wide as opposed to 96". The area of leaverage that the water pressure has to create crazing is irrelevent. And the back of the tank which, although is 96" long, should be fine as well being that there is a 15" wide overflow tower fused to the inside of the tank that creates ample support and divids the 96" long run of .5" acrylic into two 40.5" runs of .5" acrylic that are 30" high... That should be fine. Maybe a little bowing but not like a 96" run of .5". So increasing the front replacement panes thickness by .25" will increase the force of water pressure needed to create crazing or future failure. Therefore lowering the amount of outward bowing and stress on the acrylic. It all comes down to joint quality at that point. There are still 300g tanks being made of .5" acrylic that are garanteed to be structurally sound for years! I have plans to reenforce the top and bottom corners of that new pane as well as the top and bottom seams...

Technically I probably could go with .5" acrylic again being that most crazing of this manner is cause from poor manufacturing of the aacrylic from the beginning... As long as I get some from a reputable Manufacturer. But, I'd wrather not have the amount of bowing that .5" would cause....

I think that a little extra time spent removing the old and installing the new pane will be well worth the savings of $1500+ on a new tank...
 
Oh I plan on doing the work myself..... There's no other way. If I can learn Plumbing, Electrical, Rough and Finish carpetry, PC hardware and Software Troubleshooting as well as learning the basic ins and outs of Genetics on my own, I should be able to handle a little plastic welding.... No?

Look at like this. If water pressure is solely based off of "depth of the water"... And that pressure will have more leverage on longer run of acrylic (i.e. 8ft x 30" high) to put enough stress to cause crazing, then the sides will be fine being that they are only 24" wide as opposed to 96". The area of leaverage that the water pressure has to create crazing is irrelevent. And the back of the tank which, although is 96" long, should be fine as well being that there is a 15" wide overflow tower fused to the inside of the tank that creates ample support and divids the 96" long run of .5" acrylic into two 40.5" runs of .5" acrylic that are 30" high... That should be fine. Maybe a little bowing but not like a 96" run of .5". So increasing the front replacement panes thickness by .25" will increase the force of water pressure needed to create crazing or future failure. Therefore lowering the amount of outward bowing and stress on the acrylic. It all comes down to joint quality at that point. There are still 300g tanks being made of .5" acrylic that are garanteed to be structurally sound for years! I have plans to reenforce the top and bottom corners of that new pane as well as the top and bottom seams...

Technically I probably could go with .5" acrylic again being that most crazing of this manner is cause from poor manufacturing of the aacrylic from the beginning... As long as I get some from a reputable Manufacturer. But, I'd wrather not have the amount of bowing that .5" would cause....

I think that a little extra time spent removing the old and installing the new pane will be well worth the savings of $1500+ on a new tank...

:clap:clap:clap
Very impressive. Can't wait to see how it turns out!
 
:clap:clap:clap
Very impressive. Can't wait to see how it turns out!


Okay, So I got th tank home and notice some crazing at the seams and I've heard mixed options...

Some say that this type of crazing is "of some concern" and others have said that they have "had tanks that had this crazing from not long after purchase and the tank has lasted for close to 20 years and that it's nothing at all to worry about..."

Here is a few pics of the crazing that I'm referring to.


1013619.jpg

1013594.jpg

This is my thinking pattern......

IF, I'm going to be replacing the front pane of Acrylic with a new .75" pane, Maybe even 1".... I WILL have to take .25" off of the width of each side... Meaning, that I will be taking most of that crazing on the edge out via a router bit. So when I attach the new pane of acrylic, I may also add a square support dowel on each edge to enhance longevity of the tank...

1013619.jpg

1013594.jpg
 
Yes, I have done some reserch....;)

I will keep the thread up to date as possible. I traded in about 12 Trophs (8 sub-adults and 5 fry) yesterday and took home 80lbs. of Caribsea Aragonite: Reef Grade Sand for the tank... This will be added to the 65-70lbs. in the 180gallon tank of the same substrate...

Still trying to hunt down the right acrylic fro the right price as well! Still thinking about the Cell Cast .75" x 8ft x 30in quote for $300 that I got from a local supplier. But also checking on the locel forums as well! A few leads out there but not to much at this point.

Here are the 18 F2 Cyphotilapia Gibberosa Mobas that will be inhabiting the tank...

1013663n.jpg

1013665.jpg

1013669.jpg

1013670.jpg

1013671.jpg

1013672.jpg

1013675.jpg

1013677.jpg

1013679.jpg

1013709.jpg

1013716.jpg

1013663n.jpg

1013665.jpg

1013669.jpg

1013670.jpg

1013671.jpg

1013672.jpg

1013675.jpg

1013677.jpg

1013679.jpg

1013709.jpg

1013716.jpg
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com