Brian G;3905342; said:
I was leaning more towards epoxy paint or liquid rubber, something I could paint on. I guess I was just wondering if say epoxy would not crack or ultimately last longer than liquid rubber or viseversa?
Most of the sealants can be applied with methods similar to painting. Some do need to be troweled on, however. Epoxy resin can be thinned to act more like an epoxy paint if you like.
As far as what's tried and true, all of the twenty year plus plywood tanks I know of were sealed with epoxy resin, epoxy paint or a high quality polyester resin. But that doesn't mean they'll last longer than Liquid Rubber of other elastomeric emulsions because these types of sealants have not been around as long.
There is no perfect sealant for plywood tanks. All have their tradeoffs. When I consider a sealant there are five tradeoffs I consider. In no particular order:
1) Long term durability.
2) Ease of application (including solvent odor, fussy mix ratios, etc.)
3) Repairability in case of future leaks. Not every coating will accept another layer after being in a submerged environment for a year. Some are better than others.
4) Total cost, factoring in recommended thickness, percent solids, etc.
5) Silicone adhesion.
Only you can decide which of these are most important to you.