Second Shortnose is finally home.....

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Hopefully TFD gets more in, I always loved the prices of their shortnoses. (mine have always been from there).
 
Pejelajarto;4459546; said:
Huh... I'll have to pass this by my cohort Sol for a second opinion and diagnosis but the fish pictured there is not a Platostomus but rather Platyrhincus.

got your message Richard (and i agree).

looks like TFD has reverted back to their earlier "expertise" in gar ID...they definitely sent you a Florida gar, not a shortnose gar. i am not arguing that they don't have good prices on gars, they just suck at ID historically (got better for a while, but i would try to work out some sort of deal if i were you for an actual shortnose).--
--solomon
 
why cant lfs ever get the ID part right! its only a bit of research for gods sake! either way you have some great looking gars there!
 
No wonder they said it was their last one. They probably didn't realize they were out until after you paid and just gave you a Florida instead.

It could be a straight mis-ID, but from the Shorties I have gotten from there (one dead now, one alive, both confirmed as platostomus) I know they definitely had a Shortnose stock for a while.
 
dang that sucks. really wish that Craig was still on here
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com