Setting up a Stingray Tank

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

ian8834

Jack Dempsey
MFK Member
Oct 8, 2008
85
0
36
Southern Indiana
I recently purchased a 125-gallon tank. Originally, I had 3 massive oscars and a 12" pleco in there. Today, I traded those Oscars for $50 of store credit from a store close to my home. I then used this credit to buy one African knifefish, one needlenose gar, and one elephant nose.

So right now in my 125-gallon aquarium, I have the following:

(1) 12" pleco
(1) 4" needlenose gar
(1) 4" elephant nose

In my 20-gallon, I have the following:
(1) 4" African butterfly
(1) 5" African knifefish

Over the next two weeks, I am going to try and turn my big tank into a stingray tank. Next week, I will take out all decoration and gravel, and then add sand. Then the week after that, I hope to add a stingray. The pleco will be removed from the tank and sold before the stingray is added.

Here are a few questions and concerns...

(1) Are all of these fish, even the ones in the 20-gallon, compatible with a stingray? I think all of them should be fine except for the elephant nose, but I was wondering everyone elses opinion.

(2) The elephant nose likes to dig around in the bottom of the tank. Will he be fine with sand?

(3) The elephant nose currently has a hiding place he really likes. When I add the stingray, should I leave the hiding place for him?

(4) Should I add plants to the tank when I add sand? I have researched all of the fish, and the needlenose gar and elephant nose both appear to prefer tanks with plants. If I should add plants, what kind, and where should I position them so they won't interfere with the stingray?

(5) I have 2 bigger pieces of driftwood in there now. Should I leave them in the tank once the sand has been added? If so, where should they go as to not disturb the stingray?

(6) The guy at the pet store told me to only add sand that was made specifically for aquariums. He tried to sell me twenty 5-lb. bags at $3 each (total of $60). I can go and buy sand from other places for like $6-8 for 50 lbs. Would that stuff work instead? Or is it something I should research first? I would love it if I could save $40 and have no adverse affects on the fish.

(7) What kind of stingray should I get? I was originally thinking a teacup, because they're rather cheap, but have since read on here that they aren't very hardy when young. I want to buy one that is fairly hardy. Also, I don't want to spend a ton of money on one, as I have invested a great deal of money in the aquarium already. What are other kinds of rays that are available at a decent price range? (Teacup would have cost me around $55. Not looking to spend more than $80-ish)
 
i would say the pleco is a no go with ray's...due to the fact that the pleco will suck all the slime off the ray and the pleco might scare the ray and the ray might sting it. as for the 125gal tank for a ray...no go as well....the smallest ray will grow 18'' disk diamiter. a foot print tank for a ray< minmum is 6'x3'x2....would be ideal. sand is good for all the fish you currently have....IMO.
 
haynchinook334;2288250; said:
i would say the pleco is a no go with ray's...due to the fact that the pleco will suck all the slime off the ray and the pleco might scare the ray and the ray might sting it. as for the 125gal tank for a ray...no go as well....the smallest ray will grow 18'' disk diamiter. a foot print tank for a ray< minmum is 6'x3'x2....would be ideal. sand is good for all the fish you currently have....IMO.
The shop I am getting the ray from is giving me credit for my pleco. I am only keeping him in there now because he has done a hell of a job keeping it clean, and I want to keep it as clean as possible until I get the gravel out.

I will measure my aquarium. I think it is over 6' long. Not too sure about the other measurements, but I think it's big enough for a ray.
 
I've started rays in 55 gallon tanks before. Just need to upgrade as needed. God knows not all of us here have tanks big enough for adult rays but keep them anyways.... Just make sure you have the ability and means to upgrade when needed. a 125 should last you a while but like mentioned..... Definetly not forever.
 
DB junkie;2289009; said:
I've started rays in 55 gallon tanks before. Just need to upgrade as needed. God knows not all of us here have tanks big enough for adult rays but keep them anyways.... Just make sure you have the ability and means to upgrade when needed. a 125 should last you a while but like mentioned..... Definetly not forever.
Oh, I completely understand. The whole reason I have the 125-gallon is because my Oscars outgrew the 55-gallon. I will definitely upgrade as needed.

What kind of ray should I be getting, since I am new to keeping rays?
 
Yes deffinatly be prepared to upgrade and I would highly suggest doing more reaurch on rays before you just go out and buy one, they usally dont last if you do that. The ray to get is a motoro ray because they are hardiest and are the best eater and come at a rather cheap price when talking rays but that is $150 range. I would not do plants or driftwould in a 125 because you are going to want all the swiming room possible. For the sand you can do any sand as long as it doesnt have silica in it. Also look at the stickies for more information they will save you time from looking throuhg all the web sites that just say :bs:
 
ian8834;2288212; said:
I recently purchased a 125-gallon tank. Originally, I had 3 massive oscars and a 12" pleco in there. Today, I traded those Oscars for $50 of store credit from a store close to my home. I then used this credit to buy one African knifefish, one needlenose gar, and one elephant nose.

So right now in my 125-gallon aquarium, I have the following:

(1) 12" pleco no
(1) 4" needlenose gar prob get eaten
(1) 4" elephant nose not sure on this one

In my 20-gallon, I have the following:
(1) 4" African butterfly prob get eaten
(1) 5" African knifefish are these not a agressive knife species??

Over the next two weeks, I am going to try and turn my big tank into a stingray tank. Next week, I will take out all decoration and gravel, and then add sand. Then the week after that, I hope to add a stingray. The pleco will be removed from the tank and sold before the stingray is added.
odds are your gonna get a retic from your lfs...id keep barebottom for a few weeks make sure ray is eating well and you got your params straight
Here are a few questions and concerns...

(1) Are all of these fish, even the ones in the 20-gallon, compatible with a stingray? I think all of them should be fine except for the elephant nose, but I was wondering everyone elses opinion. answered to best i can

(2) The elephant nose likes to dig around in the bottom of the tank. Will he be fine with sand? if it rams its nose in gravel the sand will be softer ;)

(3) The elephant nose currently has a hiding place he really likes. When I add the stingray, should I leave the hiding place for him? yes

(4) Should I add plants to the tank when I add sand? I have researched all of the fish, and the needlenose gar and elephant nose both appear to prefer tanks with plants. If I should add plants, what kind, and where should I position them so they won't interfere with the stingray?
ray will move them anyway.... so dont matter

(5) I have 2 bigger pieces of driftwood in there now. Should I leave them in the tank once the sand has been added? If so, where should they go as to not disturb the stingray? where ever you want to put them

(6) The guy at the pet store told me to only add sand that was made specifically for aquariums. He tried to sell me twenty 5-lb. bags at $3 each (total of $60). I can go and buy sand from other places for like $6-8 for 50 lbs. Would that stuff work instead? Or is it something I should research first? I would love it if I could save $40 and have no adverse affects on the fish.

regular yellow bar sand works great.... so does quickcrete play sand and you only want a thin layer of sand

(7) What kind of stingray should I get? I was originally thinking a teacup, because they're rather cheap, but have since read on here that they aren't very hardy when young. I want to buy one that is fairly hardy. Also, I don't want to spend a ton of money on one, as I have invested a great deal of money in the aquarium already. What are other kinds of rays that are available at a decent price range? (Teacup would have cost me around $55. Not looking to spend more than $80-ish)

teacup is only ray your gonna get that cheap.... just make sure you have some black worms and prazipro... keep the water pristine and ray should be fine....
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com