Looks like a Heros Efasciatus Severum to me. The rotkeil at juvenile size have faint redish color around the gill and head area. Some do color better then others. Meaning late bloomers! These guys can be rather tricky to id at times. Did you get them both from the same place?
The top photo, fish has some good coloring. I would wait and see what happens. If those pigmentations color up i just might be. Where did you get them from if you don't mind me asking?
Ohhh ok thanks! And yes they came from the same place... they are quite small still. Barely 2”
They do have some reddish/brown dots around the gills... maybe I need better pics lol. Hard to get when they are constantly moving.