Sexing trimac cichlid

[Cichlidobssesed]

Can you guys help me out? Here is a picture of venting the three trimacs I have rn, in order 1 2 and 3. Whats you guys opinion on there sex?

 

[Andy woods cichlids uk]

Trimacs are easy to sex in the tank imo. No need to stress them and vent.

 

[Andy woods cichlids uk]

Let them chill and settle. You will soon see the sex differences.

 

[Cichlidobssesed]

Let them chill and settle. You will soon see the sex differences.

Yours are for sure easy but in my own in experience mine seem alittle unclear and I've received mixed responses on them, after day to they colored up and have happy eaten two meals. The one I thought was a male I have had for a while and it is a habit of mine to snap a quick picture of the vent when I place new fish in there tank so his vent picture was old. The other two I also took when I put them in there tanks, the two new ones where sold to me from COTA as females but dont show the classic black fin spot.

 

[Cichlidobssesed]

Let them chill and settle. You will soon see the sex differences.

Here is my "male"

 

[newworld]

Both look like males from the pics

 

[Cichlidobssesed]

This is exactly why I posted the vent pics, sold as females. Sent pictures to a local trimac breeder and he said female for the top one and others have said male

 

[Drgnball]

Can someone please determine male or female?

 

[Hybridfish7]

Can someone please determine male or female?

View attachment 1523805

Female