Thanks! I was fishing for bass with a worm on a big hook and a bobber. They don't get hooked, they just won't let go of the worm. I've caught quite a few this way - even more fishing worms on the bottom. These newts really are incredibly common here, you could catch dozens of them with a dip net in no time. The terrestrial morphs are less common, but I still see a lot of them.
Genetically there's no difference, but they do undergo significant physiological changes - skin texture and tail shape change drastically. Some newts will go back and forth between phases. Other newts will never live a terrestrial life phase.