Stock Reshuffling

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

NCStateFisher

Polypterus
MFK Member
Sep 27, 2010
3,814
123
96
NC
I know this is a lot to read.. so thanks in advance

So my little firemouth is finally big enough to go in the bigger tank (he's up to around 1.5") and im now faced with some considerations. Let me start off with listing my stock

45 gallon - 2 senegals, ABK, Opaline Gourami, Single Giant Danio (will explain later on) and 2 spotted pictus cats. (all the fish are young, everything but ABK and sens under 3")

10 gallon - juvy firemouth, 2 emerald cories

The only thing set in stone are the 2 sens and ABK in the 45, and the cories & danio in the 10.

My original plan was to put the gourami in the 10 gallon when the firemouth was ready to be switched, but honestly my gourami has become my favorite fish and i'd hate to downgrade his tank size. He's probably 2.5" now so bigger than the firemouth but I'm concerned if i put them both in the 45 the firemouth will harass the gourami (even though the firemouth barely pays attention to his 2 cory tankmates now other than a short chase here and there). He's the last of my original 3 tropical fish, i used to keep all natives when i was a kid.

The single danio was part of a school I had, they all loved to chase each other. They decided it would be fun to all swim headfirst up my filter intakes -__- he's the only one that was intelligent enough to not swim up it so he is going in to the 10 gallon.

The pictus cats honestly were irresponsible. I admit, i had just always really liked them and finally gave in and got one on impulse a few days ago. He was doing good but didnt really interact with any of the other fish so I went and got another to pair them up today, but so far while they swim together they're very nippy with each other and more aggressive than a playing sort of way, so im strongly considering returning them although they are both healthy.

So here are my options:

45- 2 sens, ABK , Firemouth, Gourami (if last 2 won't fight)
10 - Cories & Danio (probably add a small school of barbs or tetras)

or

45- 2 sens, ABK, Firemouth, 1x Pictus (the new guys going back regardless he's aggressive as heck)
10 - Gourami, Danio, Cories

Basically here's what it comes down to.

Do you guys think the firemouth would attack the gourami? and if u think he will and i go with sens, abk, firemouth - would i be able to add either a female convict or maybe a green sev? or would the convict nip my ABK's fins? Thanks again
 
at the size the firemouth is at ( 1.5 inch ) i wouldnt worry about it. only think id worry about is the sen and african knife picking on the firemouth. better to wait tell the firemouth hits 2 to 2.5 inch before risking with the sen and AKF
 
I really doubt they'll fight.
Just try it for a couple minutes and check for any problems, if they hate each other they'll show it, most likely the gourami will be interestied in the FM and touch him with her "feelers".
My FM gets along with my gourami no problem.
 
only thing about that my sens are probably only 3" and ABK maybe 5 but the only fish he's ever had a problem with was that 2nd pictus, he was too much of a wuss to go after a neon tetra actually haha
 
GhostShrimpMan;4588732; said:
I really doubt they'll fight.
Just try it for a couple minutes and check for any problems, if they hate each other they'll show it, most likely the gourami will be interestied in the FM and touch him with her "feelers".
My FM gets along with my gourami no problem.

yeah he loves to swim up to everything in the tank and check em out haha, every time i add a new fish he's all over it - he even does it to my fingers when im cleaning the gravel now lol - if they get along i could have the 2 sens, abk, gourami, and firemouth, not sure what if anything would/could be added at that point.. possibly a small convict but would that A) be overstocked or B) would the convict go after the ABKs fins or the gourami?
 
haha imo DONT add the con. mean lil buggers! even females are. got a plan to upgrade to? a 55 should work well ( how big does a african knife get? ) if you get a 55 then you may get away with a small con but grow it from 1 inch though
 
im getting a 100 sometime next year, brown knives are incredibly slow growers and typically reach 8-10" from what i understand
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com