Thinking about adding an aro to my community tank

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

knobhill

Redtail Catfish
MFK Member
May 2, 2007
1,592
608
150
IN A PLACE
I know, the title is misleading, this is a community tank of mostly larger fish. I have a 175g with many large plecos, a couple discus, 8 red severums, 18" fire eel, 5 large black ghosts knives, and a dozen or so cory cats. If i started with a small aro or two (4-5 inches), how long would it be before he tried to eat the cories?
Would they try to eat the cories at all?
Which aro would be the best fit for this tank?

Tank is not overstocked...it is over filtered if anything and I do weekly 30% water changes. Nitrates never peak above 10ppm.

Thanks
 
the general rule with arowanas is, don't keep them with anything they could fit in their mouth.. silver arowanas aren't highly aggressive, and with enough space don't tend to pick fights with their tank mates... small arowanas do grow fast though because they're pretty much always hungry.. your growing arowana could eventually see them as food.. probably within a month or two and maybe sooner... since the cory's have the spines your arowanas could choke on them..

my silver arowana grew from 7" to 24" in a year, with daily feeding of a highly varied diet.. people say you can regulate their food and "slow" their growth, but that's not a solution obviously..

as far as temperament goes, my arowana is VERY chill.. she rarely bothers anyone else in the tank (she lives with a big pleco, a large oscar, a large jack dempsey, and a large green terror).. recently we added a 7" jardini arowana to the mix, and they actually get along fine.. i don't keep discus, but i've heard their fragile, if they're large enough they could be ok.. maybe someone else will weigh in on that...

the silver arowana is less aggressive than the jardini arowana... black arowanas are also available but they tend to be a lot more expensive!

to address your idea of having one OR two arowanas, anyone would tell you having two in a tank is risk.. we did it because we knew our arowana was very relaxed and not very territorial, and the jardini was small enough that it worked (they tend to be more on the aggressive side)...

now.. if you're planning on getting two arowanas that are equal in size and raising them together that is your best bet for having them get along... the size of your tank will pose a problem in the long run... to house one or even two arowanas you need at least a 300g tank... they need lots of room to swim!

so in your decision to purchase an arowana, you need to plan for expanding your aquarium set up in less than 3 years... we'll keep our 180 for another year or so, but will definitely have to move our arowanas over to a larger tank once our jardini gets to be full grown and the silver is full grown (they can get to up to 3 feet in some cases)...

hope that helps!
-kyra
 
A 4-5" aro would likely meet it's doom in your tank. I would start with a 10"er. With that said your tank is not really big enough to house an adult arowana.
 
Watch those plecos with your discus and fire eel. Ive heard They love to eat slime coats of flat fish and slow moving fish.
 
I thin a leichardti would be your best bet kind od expensive but i heard they are super mellow and they look very nice.
 
Bennlfer;3929723; said:
Watch those plecos with your discus and fire eel. Ive heard They love to eat slime coats of flat fish and slow moving fish.

The plecos mind themselves..they are more occupied with pleco territory than any of the other fish. The only fish to be sucked on (can i write that?) by any pleco I've ever kept was a sting ray.
 
scriving;3929773; said:
I thin a leichardti would be your best bet kind od expensive but i heard they are super mellow and they look very nice.

Thanks,
I will look into that.
 
i dont suggest keeping aros under 6" with any other fish as they cant really defend themselves at a small size
 
i got a 14inch jar with 8 discus anywhere from 4inch to 9icnh and he never bothers them also have a 14inch fire eel with a very large pleco so u should be fine i do feed them heavy so not to start any trouble
 
i dont know about your arrowana but my jardini will not chase smaller fish that are very small to him. but if it is half his size then he will chase them and strip them. and it seems that my jar is arrissive to my bettas and gourimi. but not to my neons and my kribensis and cory. he is also a picky picky eater and will only take glassworms and frozen bloodworms
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com