So what would be better musky or northern pikeI hear they are extremely hard to keep in captivity and only live up to around 12-18 inches and die
This. As already stated your esox will die in that pond most likely. 5 feet of water is going to get way too warm IMHO for pike or tigers, grass and redfins can tolerate higher temps much easier than pike or musky.nether as the pond will get to warm for them your best bet for esox is Grass or red fin pickerel. might be able to do a chain pickerel but i dont know enough about them to say for sure.