to pike or not to pike?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

channarox

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Nov 27, 2007
16,973
6
0
32
south east asia
xingu I.
get one or not get one?
will be with mainly pbass and some other SA fish.
or will it kill everything?
 
i dont think it will kill everything. my pikes have been very peaceful with other SA cichlids and all are quite a bit smaller. altho it is hit or miss depending on the pikes personality. i think its worth trying. pikes rock
 
They won't kill eveything, their aggro is usually geared at conspecific aggro. All mine do
great with Vieja/Paratheraps and Parachromis species and SDs.
 
just the orange pikes?
ive heard that theyre on the higher end of the aggression scale.
plus im not keeping it with cichlids,other than the pbass.
much less aggressive fish.
 
channarox;2341778; said:
just the orange pikes?
ive heard that theyre on the higher end of the aggression scale.
plus im not keeping it with cichlids,other than the pbass.
much less aggressive fish.

As for as with Cichla, I know the Joey ( R1_Ridah) keeps a piebald pike with his. As long as neither is too large to eat the other. Plus the pikes tend
to hang in the bottom 1/3 of the tank and the cichla are more of a mid water
fish.
X1 can be buttheads, Mine tended to hoard all the food when possible but didn't abuse the others. If you are going to do an X1 try to do so with a female much better coloration.
 
they should do fine with other non-aggresive fish. what other SA fish r u thinking about? for the msot part as long as they cant fit in the pikes mouth and arent to slow they should be fine
 
ShadowStryder;2341994; said:
As for as with Cichla, I know the Joey ( R1_Ridah) keeps a piebald pike with his. As long as neither is too large to eat the other. Plus the pikes tend
to hang in the bottom 1/3 of the tank and the cichla are more of a mid water
fish.
X1 can be buttheads, Mine tended to hoard all the food when possible but didn't abuse the others. If you are going to do an X1 try to do so with a female much better coloration.

yeah,i know joey has a pike with his bass.
and it is UGLY.:grinno::grinno::grinno:
i cant tell male and females apart at the size they are now.
but i think i will get one in these few days if not sold already.
 
its_an_obsession;2342098; said:
they should do fine with other non-aggresive fish. what other SA fish r u thinking about? for the msot part as long as they cant fit in the pikes mouth and arent to slow they should be fine

not sure.
basically some predators.
pbass,if i could,armatus,if not some redtail payara,maybe a larger pike characin.
basically all i have planned for now.
 
The pike characin might not work, if it resembles a pike it will most likely receive some undo pike aggression. I'd stick with high bodied fish convicts, silver dollars, veja. Torpedo shaped fish ususally bring out the worst in pikes.
 
turtle_slayer;2342259; said:
The pike characin might not work, if it resembles a pike it will most likely receive some undo pike aggression. I'd stick with high bodied fish convicts, silver dollars, veja. Torpedo shaped fish ususally bring out the worst in pikes.

unfortunately,most of the fish i like keeping are pike-like in shape.
meaning they arent high body fish.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com