Tragedy - But What Next?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Which Stocking Option

  • Cichla intermedia

    Votes: 1 33.3%
  • Siniperca scherzeri

    Votes: 2 66.7%

  • Total voters
    3

Kayden

Polypterus
MFK Member
Jul 12, 2018
217
359
87
23
Arkansas
Hey guys, Very bad news. Due to a Water change Mishap my large male red terror passed away on Saturday. It really has left me reeling and upset with my 150 gallon tank. So i will be selling off my remaining stock and restarting it with a bit more thought put into it.

So that leads me to my future stocking. Tank is a 5'x2' 150 gallon, Ideally the tank will be planted with both rocks and driftwood, but not a super big emphasis on scape. so keep that in mind when reading these.

Option 1: Start with 6 Cichla intermedia - Grow them out to sexable size and keep the pair that seems most compatible.
I know the tank is small and most likely not conducive to a pair of cichla and a full scape long term, so I would probably remove a lot of the hardscape as they grew and switch it out for slate to breed on, It also helps intermedia are a smaller SP, but would be willing to do kelberi as well

Option 2: a Group of Sinaperca
the two species I have in mind for this are schertzi and chautsi. I would want 3-4, ideally more if finances allow. Perhaps a group of dithers since the bioload would be less than cichla.


What option do you think I should go with. Price is also a consideration for me, and by my estimates the sinipera are about 2x the price of cichla, and I would not be able to recoup the cost by selling off a few as they grew.

Let me know your thoughts and opinions, I would love to hear what you would do if you had this tank!
 
So sorry about your male Festae i have a 10in female Festae that i'm pretty attached to and have thought within my head what i would do if something happened to her and i've decided i would get a bunch of Sveni. I see the Sinaperca also get 18-24in.
 
So sorry about your male Festae i have a 10in female Festae that i'm pretty attached to and have thought within my head what i would do if something happened to her and i've decided i would get a bunch of Sveni. I see the Sinaperca also get 18-24in.
The sherzeri that I am looking at max out around 12-14, the chautsi do get about the same size as the PBass but are less active from what i have seen
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com