Trimac tank mates
- Thread starter Markl86
- Start date
Well, long term I'm not sure a trimac will live with the loaches. They get big and mean and may pick on/beat the clowns. But right off the bat, adding 2 of just about any species of cichlid is a bad idea. One will be dominant and eventually pick on the other, and with only one other in the tank all the abuse is directed to that one subdominant fish. What's your intended end game for the tank? Without more info, I'd say add at least three small juvies at the same time to help minimize aggression issues for a while.
+1. Something like the trimac will constantly stress the loaches, overall compromising their health.
As put by Emma Turner (although with Malawi cichlids), this is what happens to loaches with aggressive cichlids:
www.loaches.com
Not to mention the general habitat differences. Clown loaches prefer softer, more acidic, warmer, and faster flowing water than Central American cichlids, and generally I would not keep loaches with cichlids for the reasons outlined here.
As put by Emma Turner (although with Malawi cichlids), this is what happens to loaches with aggressive cichlids:
Why Loaches Should Not Be Kept With Malawi Cichlids — Loaches Online
An overview of why these two very different types of fish are not suitable for housing together.
Not to mention the general habitat differences. Clown loaches prefer softer, more acidic, warmer, and faster flowing water than Central American cichlids, and generally I would not keep loaches with cichlids for the reasons outlined here.
I ma trying to find pearsei and fenestratus marble cichlids as these are stunning and quiet mellow. I can't seem to get them in Ireland thoe and have no idea where and how to get them shipped. That was my plan. Although I have 20 trimac fry I'm probably better off growing them out and selling until I find the end game I really want. Thanks for the reply
For just 2 pearsei alone, an 800 L tank would be temporary at best (maybe about 2 years). Although they are less aggressive, than the 2 other cichlid species, when they feel crowded get edgy, and at 2 years they would make an 800L tank look like a kids fish bowl.
I have kept all 3 cichlids you mention, and do not think of either fenestratus, or trimaculatus as " community types.
With the non-cichlid tank mates a sort of detente may be possible for a while, but I would only think that size tank as viable for a pair, no other fish, (especially the crowd mentioned).
My trimaculatus pair would tolerate no other fish, in their similar size tank even as sub adults.
And fenestratus were not much less intolerant when I kept them.
I'd like to be proven wrong, so i case you do either of 3 versions, be sure to report back results.
I have kept all 3 cichlids you mention, and do not think of either fenestratus, or trimaculatus as " community types.
With the non-cichlid tank mates a sort of detente may be possible for a while, but I would only think that size tank as viable for a pair, no other fish, (especially the crowd mentioned).
My trimaculatus pair would tolerate no other fish, in their similar size tank even as sub adults.
And fenestratus were not much less intolerant when I kept them.
I'd like to be proven wrong, so i case you do either of 3 versions, be sure to report back results.
Last edited:
Il be getting an upgrade of a 1200 ltr tank. I'm trying hard to find bocourti and pearsei as I live in Ireland and I don't think you can ship them from the USA. Would pearsei and bocourti be a better mix with clown loach as that's my dream set up. If I do find pearsei and bocourti. I will probably grow the trimac in a separate tank and sell them.
Since both pearsei, and bocourti are primarily vegetarians, that alone might make them better tank mates for the loaches (eliminating the predation factor of the trimacs), although I have no personal experience keeping either cichlids with loaches.
And the 1200 L (300 gal) tank would be a step in the right direction.
That size tank is where both species ended up when I kept them.
And the 1200 L (300 gal) tank would be a step in the right direction.
That size tank is where both species ended up when I kept them.
I would not want to mix those species of cichlids with the carnivorous loaches. Something like this will likely occur from eating too much of the loaches' food:
www.monsterfishkeepers.com
Not to mention, clown loaches need softer water than C. pearsei and C. bocourti.
Pearsei need help asap
Found him like this today. Could this be dropsey? Im planning on moving him to another tank for treatment but im not sure how to proceed. @DMD123 Kids are going to be crushed Ammonia and nitrite are undetectable. Nitrate currently between 10 and 20.
www.monsterfishkeepers.com
Not to mention, clown loaches need softer water than C. pearsei and C. bocourti.