I picked up a sheet of 3/4" Polyshield for $11.11 after tax. It came in a 4x8 sheet, and worked perfectly. I cut it down to size with a cake knife. I'm using the extra underneath my sump in the bottom of the stand.
The Polyshield is white with a silver backing. If you put your hand to it, you can feel the heat reflect.
Also, make sure that you are supporting your FRAME, since your tank is glass. Manufacturers usually do not recommend foam under the tanks, so check and make sure it's not voiding the warranty. If it is the tank from CL, I'd feel fine with it so long as I was under the plastic frame and not just supporting the glass. However, when you do the math on a standard 180g, it's 1728 sq in supporting ~1800lbs, so a shade over 1lb/sq in, and that's not bad. It won't compress much, but it should alleviate any high spots.
HTH.