thanks bro , he is a pretty mean fish too but i came back on because ive been checking the babies out , the dad is really fighting them off better and he is actually fertilizing the eggs but they are still eating them though . if this happens again they will know what to do . they just didn't take control fast enough , i got here about 9pm and this was already happening . its 1140pm now and the mom is looking around for them . hope they don't fight about them latter . ill keep you posted ...