Unknown territory!

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

esoxlucius

Balaclava Bot Butcher
MFK Member
Dec 30, 2015
3,965
15,284
194
UK
Have you tested your water?
Yes
If I did not test my water...
  1. ...I recognize that I will likely be asked to do a test, and that water tests are critical for solving freshwater health problems.
Do you do water changes?
Yes
If I do not change my water...
  1. ...I recognize that I will likely be recommended to do a water change, and water changes are critical for preventing future freshwater health problems.
I mentioned in a recent thread that my RTGG injured himself, possibly on driftwood or rock. He lost a couple of scales but he's done this before. Usually he heals pretty quick and all's well after a few days, no medication needed.

But not this time!!

His latest injury has got gradually worse, not helped by my bala sharks picking at the wound. More surrounding scales have become dislodged and it looks quite a mess now. I started a 3 day treatment of Melafix on Wednesday. The idea, I believe, is to treat for three consecutive days and then do a water change on the fourth. So I treated Wednesday, Thursday and Friday, and this morning was my usual water change day.

The wound currently, see pic below, looks quite bad. Though it is looking a little less angry than it did before the treatment started, so I'm confident he will gradually mend.

I believe the idea with the Melafix is to carry on treatment as required, not just the three days. Obviously I'm going to have to do a lot more than just the three days thus far, so I've bought TWO more 1890ml bottles of Melafix. Those two, at the dosage required will give me 22 days treatment.

I very rarely use medicines, I hate introducing chemicals into my tank, so this really is unknown territory for me.

I have to treat him where he is, I don't have a smaller hospital tank. My main concern is that, as long as the other fish keep picking at him, this wound is never going to heal, and Melafix is damn expensive!!

I feel all I can do at the moment is blocks of three day treatment, then water change, and continue until these two large bottles of Melafix run out (about 3 weeks). I'll further assess his situation in three weeks, and hopefully I'll have some positive news.

In the meantime, have any of you guys better versed in medicating tanks got any pointers, any tricks of the trade as it were?

Below is a pic of the wound taken this morning. The white area is where scales are missing completely, usually these grow back pretty quick. The reddish area, I reckon, is where more scales may come away, I don't know at this point. And the darker area is where the healthy scales are.

IMG_20240106_104036_HDR.jpg
 
  • Wow
Reactions: SilverArowanaBoi
Sorry to hear - to be honest, melafix isn’t super effective.
I know it’s not recommended with bettas due to the way the oil coats the surface, not sure how this extends to gouramis (and specifically giant gouramis), but worth mentioning.
I’d be looking into other antibiotics like kanamycin to treat this.
Are you able to set up some sort of divider to keep the other fish from him?
 
I would say that eliminating the picking on the wound by other fish will go farther than anything else. Towards that, I suggest a temporary partition within the tank, easily done with a piece of light diffuser pane (rigid plastic), or a mesh held by a frame (not rigid mesh). It will not look pretty, and the tank’s territories will be altered temporarily (couple of weeks), but will eliminate the picking. Then, melafix or not is a choice, but with the picking, it may not be enough. That is what I would do. Good luck!
 
So Melafix is nothing more than snake oil? Typical. No wonder I hate using off the shelf products so much, not many of them do what they claim.

The tank divider is a good option, I really need to keep my balas away from him, their picking is just hindering the healing process.

I need to get my hands on a big ass piece of light diffuser now!
 
So Melafix is nothing more than snake oil? Typical. No wonder I hate using off the shelf products so much, not many of them do what they claim.

The tank divider is a good option, I really need to keep my balas away from him, their picking is just hindering the healing process.

I need to get my hands on a big ass piece of light diffuser now!
I used this to make a hood:
A bunch of small pieces that all snap together into a big one - not sure if you can get it in the UK though.
In my experience melafix hasn’t done anything to help any of my fish, and I’ve seen similar from other accounts.
It may do some mild calming and works as a bit of an antibiotic, but for the money you’re spending you might as well use something stronger. Plus melafix and birds don’t get along (only a concern if you have a bird)…
 
  • Like
Reactions: SilverArowanaBoi
Thanks for that suggestion Deadeye Deadeye . Thinking about it I do actually have a load of big sheets of double wall polycarbonate sheets in the shed. I just need to measure up, cut, drill some holes in, and position it in the tank.

It's going to be a fight pita but I'm going to have to do it.
 
Have to agree that melafix is snake oil… for any open wounds like this id remove the fish and apply a betadine solution to stop/prevent any infection from setting in and aid in healing. Smart move to divide as others suggested as well.
 
If you can find it, you can dab the area with merbromin.

If not, you can try betadine to disinfect the area as stated above and apply a liquid bandage to protect it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Deadeye
MonsterFishKeepers.com