Cambarus bartonii doesn't come in red or orange, unless someone had found a recessive gene morph but as far as I've seen they don't. They are usually black-brown, brown-green or a steely color. If you find them in sandy or muddy areas, they seem to have a more tan coloration mixed in.
In this area red or orange morphs are usually P. clarkii, C. diogenes or O. rusticus... and those are are larger longer bodied crayfish with elongated, bulky and bumpy claws.