Honestly, I'd make them fill it up. There's more to it than the price, if that thing cracks in the middle of the night you are going to do horrible things to the floor. Ask if there's any bowing, or cracks, or lines, or anything like that. Who originally made the tank? How old is it? Things of that nature. I wouldn't trust anybody that isn't willing to, or doesn't know the answer to any of those questions. Good luck with your tank.