where do these fish myths come from if not LFS????

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Retuks

Fire Eel
MFK Member
Feb 19, 2009
1,076
4
68
Kaneohe
I wonder how the hell the myth of "fish grow to the size of the tank" ever started.

even all the LFS over here says thats not true, so atleast they are on the right page. but thats where most of the info came from.. so how the hell did start???
 
people trying too look like they know stuff when they don't probs
 
People want to help, even stupid people. It's not meant maliciously mostly, but part of it comes from an expectation of perfection and fear of making a mistake and getting sued. If you actually admit that you made a mistake, that something was in any way your fault, some butthead with a lawyer will sue the ever living snot out of you. The courts should be an absolute last resort, the only people that actually benefit from lawsuits are lawyers. Don't get me started, you're dangerously close to my soapbox button.
 
i thought it was true, yielding a stunted fish with a sloped spine?
 
In my experience, it's true of goldfish. I have had several that have grown to a certain size, stayed that way for over a year, then been moved to a larger tank and they've grown some more. This has happened a number of times.
Since goldfish are the first fish people associate fish keeping with I would guess that's where it comes from.
But i could be wrong...
 
i also over heard this college brat at a small grungy mom/pop lfs talking to the young owner saying "yah, i had 2 pacu before, in my 20gallon tank. those guys lived for almost 2 years!" and saying it as if 2 years was a very long age... what makes me even more upset is the girl working there replied "wow!" to him. i wanted to throw her out.

he also mentioned that they grew perfectly to fit the tank... but i suppose "fitting the tank" is just another way to say "dying early".

this must also be how the other myth "fish keep growing for as long as they live" comes from... because it was growing up until it died.
 
you know, there are some people who think most fish have their entire life cycle within a year? an old classmate of mine was saying this about his pacu...

making everyone think they are "born, then grow, then spawn, and die during winter"... and think that fish are like bugs.

this is also why half my class assumed that all fish only live for one year... throw them into a 10 gal and when it dies they simply assume "well, it was just his time"...
 
It may also arise from experiences with native fish such as catfish, gars, and bass. A general rule being the bigger and deeper the river, creek, or lake lake the larger the fish specimens that can be found. To be more specific I often fish for flat-head, and blue cats along the white lick creek a small fairly shallow creek system. If I caught a catfish there in the 15-16 inch range I would consider it large. I fish white river a larger system on occasion and my expectations for a large fish there would be over two feet. I could continue this into the very large rivers such as the Ohio or the Mississippi and the sizes would likewise increase. That would seem to indicate that the size of the body of water in which they are living is effecting their maximum size of the fish. Therefore, It would seem reasonable that the size of aquarium a fish is kept in would, to some extent, effect its maximum size. As experienced hobbyists we have learned that this is not the case in all species and that stunting the fish's growth by confinement also adversely effects their health, so we try to keep our fish in tanks that allow them to reach more natural adult sizes.
 
Retuks;3139557; said:
I wonder how the hell the myth of "fish grow to the size of the tank" ever started.

even all the LFS over here says thats not true, so atleast they are on the right page. but thats where most of the info came from.. so how the hell did start???
I´ve personally been given a goldfish which grew to the length of the bowl it was in. The water was just a green soup. The dissolved oxygen was so variable that the fish just sat on the bottom of the bowl to conserve energy the whole time. How do I know this? Well if you´ve got a better theory why the lower back half of the tail had grown to fit the contour of the bowl just let me know:WHOA:. After putting the goldfish into a larger tank the tail changed back to normal after about 3 months.

j<><
 
its not the size of the body of water but how much food is in the body of water. for example a pond wont have more food than a river usally there for smaller or less fish then that of a larger body.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com