Which 3 are most compatible.

[arowanaryan]

I have a 180 gallon tank that I use as a growout and then I bring them to my LFS for one of there (3) 900 gallon tanks as soon as they outgrow my 180. They said they will accept anything I can get them and give a trade of fish/money for whatever they are worth... I know them personally and there is no question if they will accept my fish or not. They will.

I'm going to be getting a fish as an early birthday present, and these are the ones I'm interested in and will be ordering one of these from Aquascape or from Shark Aquarium.

Which 3 fish out of the group do you think would be most compatible with my fish?

My current stock is

1. 4 inch RTC
2. 4 inch Oscar
3. 4 inch Pacu
4. 8 inch Alligator Gar ( he is extremely docile for a gar )
5. 3.5 inch RTCxTSN hybrid
6. 10 inch silver arowana.

Now of these 8 which 3 would be most do-able with my current stock?

1. 6 inch Goliath African Tiger Fish
2. 6 inch Armatus
3. 9 inch Goonch catfish
4. 6 inch African Pike.
5. 6-8 inch Hoplias Malabaricus
6. 6-8 inch Araipima Gigas
7. 4-5 inch Dovii
8. 5 inch Golden Dorado.

I will only be buying one I just want to see what 3 people think are the best fits for my tank/stock.

 

[probassfisher010]

Uhhhh, I wouldn't get any of those...the 4 inch oscar pacu and even rtc would probably be gone/killed. I have not kept any of those fish, but I wouldn't do it.

 

[arowanaryan]

If i have to get rid of the oscar and or pacu I'm prepared to. I might get rid of the pacu anyway since he nips at my gar. The RTC hides all the time so im not concerned.... I want to know what fish could work best not if I should get them or not

 

[fwprawn]

The ONLY one I see that would actually do "OK" with your current fish is the African Pike.