***Which Wet Dry Filter?***

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

lnatividad

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Apr 7, 2007
45
0
0
So Cal
I need some serious help in choosing a wet dry filter. Which brands and why, where to buy and contact info? I have a 180G Freshwater.

Eshopps, Aqualine, Lifereef...etc. What is the best bang for the buck? Thank you.
 
I am not familiar with all of the different types of wet/dry filters out there, but from what I have read most people are way happier when they build their own from a regular glass tank (look on craigslist or wait for a good sale). They can customize it as they want. I do have a wet/dry filter on my 125g and like it (unfortunately bought it used so all I can tell you is that it is a "Pro Clear Aquatic System").

If money becomes available I will probably build my own eventually. Basically mine uses overflow boxes on my tank that run to the filter. Then it drains into a drip tray that has a filter pad (mechanical filtration) and drips the water over my bioballs. Then the water goes through another filter sponge and is pumped back to the tank. My problem with this is getting to the filter pad to clean it is somewhat of a pain (not too bad though). It would be easier to just replace it every time, but that isn't necessary and really a waste of money.

Personally I think I would like the ability to use a filter sock instead because it would be easier to get at and clean (and you can just take it off and replace with a new/clean one when necessary). Most people have water overflow from the tank and then the water is mechanically filtered through a filter sock (as already mentioned). Then the water flows under a piece of glass/acrylic siliconed in place (leaving space for water to flow under it) and over another piece of glass/acrylic (these are commonly called baffles). The next area has whatever bio media you prefer (bioballs, scrubbies, etc.) and then two more baffles (as described before) before the area where water collects and is pumped back to the tank. These are very effective according to what people say and easy to maintain (easy to get into and clean). Just take a look at the "DIY filters" section if interested.

If you don't like the idea of DIY then hope others can give you some more input.
 
I think you need to research your sump filtration options. Do you have internal/external overflow boxes? We are running a ProClear 400 wet/dry filter on our 300 gallon tank. We were novice fishkeepers when we set up our tank. We run a completely separate mechanical filtration system. The wet/dry filter is an extremely simple filter. Knowing what I know now, I would never buy another one....they are too easy to make. If I were in your position, I would build a sump filter using submerged biological media with a strong mechanical component utilizing filter socks. The filter could also be designed with a wet/dry component. Check out the DIY filtration section.
 
Or just snoop around the Buy/Sell and get a used one. Go for something that is over ratted on your Tank size... ie:Sump rated for 150gl for your 100gl tank.

DIY is your best and cheapest/effective option in most cases
 
I agree a glass tank with media like bioballs, or Matrix is very easy to make and you have more custom options like pumps, media reactors and such alot cheaper than say lifereef, nicely made but expensive!
 
Thanks guys, I am busy with work and family I dont have time to build my own. I talked to Jeff from Life Reef, cool guy but with gas prices, I think I will get something else.

I can get a great deal from Eshopps, and they are local to me. What is the best interal pump and what size to get?

I need to get overflow boxes by the way...
 
Just bought Eshopps overflow 1000 gal works well after two weeks of use and restarts w power outage
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com