Which would you chose?

[Fishdude401]

The oscar tank would include:
4 Oscars
1 Clown knife
1 Fire eel
1 Cactus pleco

The oddball tank would include:
1 Clown knife
1 fire eel
several various plecs
1 severum
several various synos

Either one that is chosen, these fish will be housed in a 55g with 1000GPH filtration, than be upgraded to probably a 150-180gallon tank.

I am torn between the two!!!

 

[Dominator]

cant vote cuz they look the same.

 

[Fishdude401]

Need more clarification, it worked for me.

 

[cichlidinsomniac]

Jeff rapps has some nice oscars right now and your in NJ.

 

[CTU2fan]

I voted "oddballs" but no reason why you couldn't do that mix plus an oscar. All the other fish are mainly bottom to midlevel fish, the oscar(s) would have most of the top half of the tank to themselves. Just wait and add a medium O once you have their permanent tank up rather than trying to jockey with growth rates in the 55.

 

[swede]

i will always vote anything oddball over oscars cuz they have become the goldfish of tropical fish. i can even go to walmart and buy albino oscars (not that i would, just saying)

 

[thor meeki]

i will always vote anything oddball over oscars cuz they have become the goldfish of tropical fish. i can even go to walmart and buy albino oscars (not that i would, just saying)

I couldn't agree more.

 

[EdCal]

go with the oscar tank, way more movement then the oddball fish you selected

 

[Tom500]

Oscars dont interest me in the slightest so oddballs all the way!

 

[Fishdude401]

Ok, im mixing:
1 Clown knife
1 Fire eel
Synos
Plecos
2 Oscars
Possibly a super red sev

Thanks for the input