Whiptail and twig catfish algae eaters

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

ColeFishing

Jack Dempsey
MFK Member
Jan 5, 2012
1,820
8
38
Ohio
1)how good are these cats at eating algae(and don't worry ill very their diet with other stuff)? and 2)how much do these fish crap?

Additional info:
Im interested in getting one of each of these cats. Algae on the glass is my second worst nightmare right behind actually having to scrape algae off the glass. i've had a marble sail fin pleco for almost a year now and he is about 6.5" long. i recently bought a rhino pleco for my 20 gallon tank to keep the algae gone and i was told they crap as much as any other pleco but whoever told me that was wrong. my rhino LITERALLY filled half footprint the tank with crap in 3 days. crap had filed the holes in the sand and it was over everything and piling up, it was gross. he is 2" long and craps more in 3 days than my MSP does in two months. I'm going to move him to another tank where his crap can't fill the entire hole in which my small raphael catfish USED to hide in. as he can't hide in it anymore because it literally filled up with crap. this is really bugging me and i am considering to get a both of those cats(one to clean my 26 bowfront and the other for my 20). I've already researched the two but can't find anything on the two questions i ask(i also know from experience some algae eaters are better than other) plus i think those to cats, especially the whiptail, look really cool.
 
Farlowellas (twig catfish) eat green algae and diatoms (brown). Right now, mine is having trouble keeping up with green hair algae in my one very well lit tank, but before I got better lights for my 16 gallon bowfront, I had to cycle that little eating machine between three different small tanks to keep him placated. It's my experience that NO algae-eating fish will eat algae if given a choice. My farlowella does not touch any sort of flake or pellet or algae disk as far as I can tell. I previously supplemented his diet with soaked nori (roasted seaweed for wrapping sushi). These and the Chinese Algae Eaters and Siamese Algae Eaters and otoniculus are VASTLY superior to plecos when it comes to eating algae, and they most certainly are NOT poop factories lilke plecos, either. I am to this day just absolutely MYSTIFIED at how popular plecos are in the aquarium trade. Farlowellas make tiny little discreet poops like what you would expect from a slender, non-predatory fish their size. I can't recommend them enough!
 
Well my marble sail fin pleco is one of my favorite fish and I have no idea why. I guess it's because he's pretty and has, over time, grown fond of me. Anyways thanks for the reply. When i get back from CO I will be picking some up and most likely returning my rhino pleco. Thanks!


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
Oh whoops! I meant to say that I do not understand how the common pleco got so popular for cleaning algae!

If someone gets them and understands the needs of the fish and what it can and can't do, that's fine. There are many many stunning pleco species out there. :-)

Sent from my LG-V909 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com