why do they keep doing this??

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

mbunafishkeeper

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Jul 24, 2007
3,582
6
0
32
Bristol (UK)
my jags keep eating there eggs after the trouble they take to actually lay them the male eats them within the next 24 hours...

they have done this numour of times and its starting to anoy me so any suggestions why or how to stop them would be great thanks.

also there in the tank on there own and shouldnt have any threats so....
 
i bred jags for some time and I noticed the same thing. Although eating the eggs is actually what there supposed to do. I would see a lot of eggs layed and then as the days would go on, there would be half the eggs there. What happens is some die due to many different reasons. Not enough sperm, poor water quality, lack of oxygen coming to eggs etc. So always some will die off. As they die off the parents will pick them off and usually eat a few good ones by accident but thats what they need to do to make sure that the majority survive. Although if they are eating all of them, then that means for some reason there all not doing well. I remember mine ate the first couple batches and then the third batch they raised.

Some suggestions

1.) Try to improve water quality. I don't know how your water is but check your temp. Temp needs to be a bit higher for the eggs but not to high because the higher the temp the less oxygen in water. I bred my jags at 80. Make sure water quality is perfect. I don't mean like 20-30 ppm nitrate I mean like 10 or less. The less the better.

2.) Do small water changes like every day or second day for now so that way the water is always good. Because once the eggs hatch you should not do any water changes for about a week. Any changes to water would cause the eggs or fry to die.

3.) How big is the tank?????

4.) is there any other fish in the tank because maybe they are not eating the eggs someone else is. Plecos and other bottom feeders love to sneek up at night and scarf down some eggs.
 
there are no other fish its definatley the male i see him picking them off. they layed last night and after the female finished off laying the male just kept attacking her shredding scales and lip locking.

the tank is 80gallons i know people say this is a lil small but shane was happy with the tank size when he sold the jags to me and he bred them in the same tank size successfully i do 60% changes weekly, i will increase if needed.

thanks for the reply.
 
wait so he's eating them right after she lays them???? he doesn't fertilize them at all???
 
no he does fertalize some of them but not all, he doesnt start eating straight away but he does about 2-3hours after.
 
how big is the male??? maybe he is not totally mature and is shootin blanks LOL sorry excuse my youth LOL

In all seriousness though he may be too young and not ready to fertilize eggs. I have seen males go over eggs thinking there fertilizing them although there really not doing anything. Instinct teaches you how to hanky spanky but if you don't got the juice then there won't be any fertilizing.

Give your male a few more months. Let them keep making eggs and keep water really good and eventually you will have fry.


Ohhh and in some cases they just need a couple tries to become good parents. I know people with Oscars have told me that young parents actually have a learning process of caring for eggs and fry.
 
he is 13" and has successfully bred for shane numorous times.
 
Maybe he eats them because he is stressed, my cubans used to do the same when they were in with bigger cichlids and could not protect the eggs. Or maybe he doesn't want the responsability or costs involved in bringing up a family.
 
Steve p;1443183; said:
Maybe he eats them because he is stressed, my cubans used to do the same when they were in with bigger cichlids and could not protect the eggs. Or maybe he doesn't want the responsability or costs involved in bringing up a family.
your jags are breeding mbuna??? can i have some fry? or buy some?
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com