Why letting goldfish go wild is a bad idea: They become giant pests

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

thebiggerthebetter

Senior Curator
Staff member
MFK Member
Dec 31, 2009
16,830
14,775
3,910
Naples, FL, USA
Another one of those. We need to up our awareness efforts as a community.

http://mashable.com/2016/08/16/giant-goldfish-australia/#k5SE_Xl5ZsqL

You may think dumping goldfish into a river is a harmless act, but in reality the fish can become destructively big.

Researchers from the Centre of Fish and Fisheries at Murdoch University have been trying to control goldfish for 12 years in the Vasse River, located in the southwest of Western Australia.

An invasive species, the goldfish is causing havoc for native fish and its surrounding ecosystem, which is why Stephen Beatty and his fellow researchers spent a year studying the little-known movement patterns of the goldfish in the wild. The results of the study, now concluded, has been published in a paper in the journal, Ecology of Freshwater Fish.

Beatty told Mashable Australia that the study was conducted because of the sharp rise in aquarium species, such as the goldfish, being detected in the Vasse River in the last 15 years. That's all thanks to people letting them go in local waterways.

"We think it's a major factor, people letting their aquarium species go. Unwanted pets, basically. They can do quite a lot of harm," Beatty said.

Goldfish are omnivores in the wild, and they can have destructive feeding habits. They deteriorate the quality of water by stirring up sediment on the bottom of river beds, dig up vegetation and also consume anything edible that comes before them — including native fish eggs.

On top of that, the goldfish compete for space and resources with native fish, and have been responsible for introducing disease.

Most startling is the fact that goldfish in the wild can grow to massive sizes, and they have an unprecedented ability to travel long distances. One goldfish found by researchers weighed 1.9 kilograms (4.1 pounds), while another was tracked travelling a marathon 230 kilometres (142 miles) in a year.

"We didn't think goldfish were that mobile," Beatty said. "What this study shows is that they are quite mobile, but I think it's mostly to do with with feeding and foraging."

Beatty said they were able to discover evidence of goldfish undergoing migration into nearby wetlands, where they are reproducing — a.k.a. a spawning migration. It's a discovery which will help researchers figure out how to stop the invasive species.

"It gives us better clarity on how to control them. That wetland has only a small opening, so we think we can manufacture some sort of trap to catch them when they go in to breed," he said.

Other removal methods include nets and electrofishing, but Beatty admits it can be difficult to remove an alien species without damaging the local fish population. As always, prevention is the cure.

"The key thing is if you've got unwanted pets, you can see if the pet shops will take them back. But if you're going to euthanise them, putting them in the freezer is the most humane way," Beatty explained.

"But just letting go of a pet, no matter how innocuous you think it is in your aquarium, or how pretty it is, can potentially cause a lot of damage. Not all fish you let go will form a self-maintaining population, but we're finding more and more that do."
 
Just read this on the bbc. I can donate them to a local garden centre pond if i cant provide for them
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
Australia is full of invasive species. Geo's are running wild in SA and NSW, goldfish are everywhere, the list goes on...

Actually a perfect example is Tassie's native galaxias, they're endangered because of trout that was introduced for sport fishing and funnily enough, the government keep the trout around for whatever reason, while complaining that the natives are threatened.. Idk, governments confuse me sometimes...

In Tasmania there is nowhere at all you can take fish if you can't care for them, I don't know about the rest of the country but I assume it wouldn't be much different. The pet shops MIGHT take the large cichlids off you if they think they can make a buck off of them but there is no way on earth I could convince a pet shop down here to take a goldfish of any size.

I would absolutely love to do what you've done with your fish rescue Victor, but I doubt I'm going to have the money/space/time for that any time soon. Maybe one day...
 
Gold Fish should be on the ban list to sell/own :p
It has amazing adaptation system.
Example:
I got little goldfish pond in my back yard and they can live through 101F in summer time and 40F in winter time as long the water not freezing up they are fine :p
 
Gold Fish should be on the ban list to sell/own :p
It has amazing adaptation system.
Example:
I got little goldfish pond in my back yard and they can live through 101F in summer time and 40F in winter time as long the water not freezing up they are fine :p
They can live under ice too
 
  • Like
Reactions: Yuki Rihwa
Great post, Viktor.....it's important that people understand this type of stuff and it's such a shame there's soooooo many endangered species just because a few ****heads feel the need to let their pets go. This is a problem on every continent, be it Pythons in S. Florida, Cane Toads in Australia, Mongooses in the Caribbean, ........the list of invasives around the world is too long to list (but I bet deserves a thread to see if we can try) and everywhere they have been introduced, the local ecosystems are suffering because of it.

I don't necessarily believe it's a matter of educating people because I truly feel that a lot of these people who release them already KNOW they shouldn't; I think a lot of it has to do with the fact that they simply don't CARE. Still, nothing much we can do except educate people, but I think Australia is on the right track by giving people $125,000 fines for possessing a RES :D

I wish the rest of the countries in the world would combat humanity in such a way that Australia does in their stance on wildlife. I'm sure it sucks to be an animal-owner in AU, but sometimes sacrifices need to be made. Not everyone should just be able to randomly buy any animal they want and I think permits should be needed for many the things we keep.....


............which is another list that is too long to make.
 
Last edited:
Where I lived in Wisconsin (northern midwest USA), goldfish are found in just about all park lagoons, and as stated above survive winters under the ice, decimate native fish populations, and get very large.
Of course carp of any kind are none native and fill the lakes, and rivers, and can reach 4ft in size, but were introduced almost a century ago. Some getting to be such a problem, entire lakes are poisoned to get rid of them, and restocked with native fish.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frank Castle
I happened to notice feeder type goldfish in a stream in East Maui for the first time about 2 weeks ago. Looked like they got a spawn off as you walked up stream ever pool seem to have a pair of golds in it. I did hear they were introduced to to some parts of Hawaii as early as 1800's but haven't become very well established and tend to wash out, unlike other parts of the world were they become invasive.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com