A awsomebichir Feeder Fish MFK Member Jun 24, 2009 354 1 0 monrovia Aug 10, 2009 #1 will it do anything or no ? just wondering because i got a built in protein skimmer on my filter and its off right now..i dont know if i should turn it on.will it hurt anything ?
will it do anything or no ? just wondering because i got a built in protein skimmer on my filter and its off right now..i dont know if i should turn it on.will it hurt anything ?
K ken 429 Candiru MFK Member Apr 14, 2007 394 0 46 central florida Aug 10, 2009 #2 theres some interesting threads on it. eheck out the search function
Bogwoodbruce Peacock Bass MFK Member Feb 2, 2007 27,290 13 119 34 Rotherham, UK www.facebook.com Aug 10, 2009 #4 Completely pointless on a freshwater tank, just a waste of electricity.
F fishdance Goliath Tigerfish MFK Member Jan 30, 2007 1,847 1,015 179 Aug 10, 2009 #5 Freshwater skimmers do have their place since removing solid waste directly will gratly reduce the load of biofilters. Particularly useful on larger fish, heavily stocked  or heavily fed fish such as rays or koi. You can use water pumps and longer water columns/paths to pulverise the water to help separation.  Not useful for a general freshwater tank but freshwater skimmers are useful.
Freshwater skimmers do have their place since removing solid waste directly will gratly reduce the load of biofilters. Particularly useful on larger fish, heavily stocked  or heavily fed fish such as rays or koi. You can use water pumps and longer water columns/paths to pulverise the water to help separation.  Not useful for a general freshwater tank but freshwater skimmers are useful.
J JakeH Fire Eel MFK Member Mar 17, 2009 1,961 1 66 Houston, TX Aug 10, 2009 #6 I've heard that larger, FW specialized ones work, but I've never tried it. My guess is the average "built-in" protein skimmer wont do much for you.
I've heard that larger, FW specialized ones work, but I've never tried it. My guess is the average "built-in" protein skimmer wont do much for you.
Redearsunfish Piranha MFK Member Aug 6, 2009 6,565 40 75 A nice lake full of game fish! topwaterreviews.blogspot.com Aug 10, 2009 #7 Won't do much unless you're able to really whip the water into a frenzy of bubbles. However, if you can do that, then yes they can work.
Won't do much unless you're able to really whip the water into a frenzy of bubbles. However, if you can do that, then yes they can work.