Yellow labs and aro? Anyone tried that?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

toffee

Candiru
MFK Member
Aug 21, 2006
159
8
48
Texas
Planning a 8ft tank for a juvi Silver Aro which is now approaching 24" and about to out grow his 6ft. I am thinking not to move his tank mates with him. How about a group of 2030 yellow labs as new tankmate? Will the labs be too small as they can sort of fit into the aro's mouth? Although matured labs are about 3.5"-4". This aro has been non aggressive, having grow up from a 6inch with cichlids. Only thing is that he never live with small cichlids. will the labs gang up on him?

Anyone tried that? ie an Aro in African tank?
 
They're more than likely going to be expensive food for your aro.
 
Are you planning on providing the labs plenty of rocky hiding places? Are you planning on adding them first? Do you ever feed your aro feeders? It's impossible to say for certain, but your best chance of success is to put the labs in there first and give them enough time to become settled in the tank (think weeks rather than days). Then add the aro and keep your fingers crossed. If you never feed the aro feeders then that will improve your chances. And keeping the aro very well fed for the first couple weeks will help as well. If willing to take the financial risk, I'd say go for it.
 
Don't bother there are really good odds that they arowana will end up with frayed fins and your cichlids will shortly go missing, Not to mention that these fish are at total opposite ends of the spectrum for water parameters.
 
I put a silver arowana in my 150g, then a few weeks later added a pair of yellow labs, among other mbuna. The yellow labs are now about 3" and 4" and the arowana is about 12". Neither of the labs have been eaten, nor has the arowana tried to, at least when I have been watching. Not to mention I don't have as many hiding places as I'd like for mbuna. I would bet that this is the exception rather than the norm. However, I have no doubt the arowana will eat the labs when he gets bigger- but he'll be moving to a 500g pond without the labs in a month or two. I'd try it in your situation, as long as you're not particularly attached to the labs and your financial situation can take the possible hit, which will be substantial with that many labs. Keep in mind though, it's more than likely that the aro will eat at least a few, in which case you should remove the labs (maybe make the old 6 foot a mbuna tank?). Also, I highly doubt the labs will gang up on the aro. Plus you have the bonus of the 8ft long big tank, that will definitely help the labs hide.

Edit: My silver aro also eats the occasional feeder when he steals them from a needlefish, but this doesn't seem to boost his aggression.
And f22; water parameters as far as pH goes, these fish have been tank bred for generation upon generation, which makes it highly likely that both the labs and aro won't be as picky about the pH (assuming neither are wild-caught). I wouldn't doubt that keeping the pH in between the preference of the aro and the labs won't harm either of them.
 
They're your fish bro, but silver arowana can get picky about ph, trust me I sell 3 or 4 of em a week... but thats really not the issue... I hope it works out for you bud. Keep us posted, I'm intrigued to see what goes south...
 
They're your fish bro, but silver arowana can get picky about ph, trust me I sell 3 or 4 of em a week... but thats really not the issue... I hope it works out for you bud. Keep us posted, I'm intrigued to see what goes south...

Do you think a full grown silver can live in a 2ft wide tank? say 8x2x2 or so? I am leaning towards that it will be too narrow for them to turn around which they do continuously.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com