I have more herps than fish, and I can see spending more money on a specific species of herp over a fish. So fish for sure. They are easier to keep, and cheaper, and most you can touch and handle.
It's funny how the people who prefer fish outnumber the herp lovers by 24 but it seems like most of the replies on here are from the herp people.
Are the rest of the fish people just too ashamed of their choice to post?