In his defense he is selling them and selling them cheap I might add so maybe he came to his senses and figured they had outgrown their tank. He does say that he has had the fish since they were little. I have a question for you knowlegeable people (since I am no one of them) How long do you suppose he has had them in that tank since it was no longer suitable for them size wise, I'm guessing they out grew their home awhile ago. But I suppose the guy is still a dumass for not knowing what he was getting himself into and if he did know he more dumb than thought. Even I , a complete novice to this hobby have known better to buy an Aro without the proper size tank. I should just get a biger tank, an Aro is the 1 fish my wife constantly wants to get