Which online retailer?

[PennReels84]

since u live in NY it should get to ur house quick as hell too!

 

[Goanna]

Well, I just ordered livestock from That Fish Place and everything came in really well. They also seem to keep the best selection of Brackish fish, F&S is always out of stock on the brackish stuff.

I've been to the actual store in lancaster PA also and it's gigantic. It's probably bigger then a Costco/Sams club. Really cool place, just too bad it's 2.5+ hours away from me.

 

[puffcrusader696]

Well, I just ordered livestock from That Fish Place and everything came in really well. They also seem to keep the best selection of Brackish fish, F&S is always out of stock on the brackish stuff.

I've been to the actual store in lancaster PA also and it's gigantic. It's probably bigger then a Costco/Sams club. Really cool place, just too bad it's 2.5+ hours away from me.

I've been there too and yes, its huge. i saw their facebook page and they said it was the biggest pet store in the world (size wise) and i have to agree. its massive in there. theres an aviary inside too! the place is friggen huge! but yes... its like 3 hours from here so its a good day trip and with gas prices my parents arent too keen on going anywhere 3 hours away for just a day...

 

[smokin]

aww **** i live like 30 mins away go there all the time...they used to have a huge red tail catfish in a koi pond inside they might still have it.. sweet fish huge lots and lots of stuff

 

[dennisdeng2002]

i have ordered from that fish place many times they always ahve free shipping over 100 dollars or spend a certian amount and get money back. plus cheaper prices. and there items at at my house in 2 days! that fish places ALL THE WAY!

I ordered from TFP too there shipping is fast but I live in MD and you live in south jersey, TFP is only a 2-5 hour drive so shipping should be fast. I still like D F&S website it's more organized and honestly the price differential isn't that much, some things are cheaper on both vendors. D F&S has legendary service but TFP has great service, it's really a draw between the two, I usually order from whatever has all the items that I want in stock. I would also look at BIG ALS they have great prices too.

 

[TheFanatic]

This is a very easy answer. When you are looking for something online, whichever place has it the cheapest. That's what I do...

 

[bigfishrcool1193]

fish tfp has better quality fish from what i've heard........

from what i've heard live aquaria (dr f & s) has fish that are in kind of bad condition and they sometimes dont send the correct fish

supplies wise i've heard many good things about dr. f & s

 

[Pyramid_Party]

No brainer, DR F & S OWN.

 

[PennReels84]

does big al's have a site??? i keep hearing about this place.

 

[puffcrusader696]

ive gotten a bunch of fish from TFP and they are really good quality, always healthy, and they'll let you know if they dont want to send a fish for health reasons. I think TFP has just as good service as Dr. F & S. and TFP fish room is HUGE!!!! bigger than any petco/petsmart ive ever been to. ive compared both and TFP has better stock and health so far...