Should MFK have a Koi Section?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Should MFK have a Koi Section?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 18 81.8%
  • No Way!

    Votes: 4 18.2%

  • Total voters
    22
  • Poll closed .
I feed Koi to my peacock bass and giant red tails... So considering koi are like gold fish and are used by some as feeders they should make a "feeders" section and put the koi there!

My fish eats yours
:ROFL:

Maybe you should try pellet training your PBass... Feeders (koi/goldfish) are HORRIBLE to feed- to anything!

Ok, let me see you pay $10,000 for a pbass! Not to mention that koi live way longer than any Pbass. (not bashing on pbass- just saying)

http://www.kodamakoifarm.com/lover/koiforsale_detail.php
 
Maybe you should try pellet training your PBass... Feeders (koi/goldfish) are HORRIBLE to feed- to anything!

Ok, let me see you pay $10,000 for a pbass! Not to mention that koi live way longer than any Pbass. (not bashing on pbass- just saying)

http://www.kodamakoifarm.com/lover/koiforsale_detail.php


I agree, and I do have most to all my PB pellet trained. The feeders I do feed (as a treat, occasionally) are Quarantined for two weeks with medicated treatment before feeding... Nothing like watching a monster PB slam a 8" to 10" feeder!! :headbang2
 
we actually do koi in the pond section and cold water/native section!
 
I do understand that it's discussed in that section, however there is no sub section for them. I think there should be as there are things that are koi related that would never relate to any other fish. Such as SVC and KHV. As well as treatments and feedings depending on temp etc.

Many ppl think that a koi is just an over sized goldfish, but its south more than that.

I've had more hardships with caring for koi than I have had with any other fish. They are not simple fish by far.
 
we actually do koi in the pond section and cold water/native section!

This was going to be part of my reply,somwhat but I don't see why not.It can't be any worse than having a reptile section on a fish forum.
 
I should also mention that KHV (Koi Herpes Virus) is something that only koi/goldfish can get. It's a HORRIBLE thing to come across, and it WILL wipe out your entire pond- causing you to have to either throw away everything that ever touched pond water, or bleach bath it. There is serology testing that gets done to determine this, and many many other things.

There are diseases that only koi/goldfish get.. for example Carp Pox.. much is unknown about this disease, and I will be doing a lot of research with this, as I have a koi that has this exact disease. There is going to be a lot of experimenting with medications and such, and I feel that it could benefit the koi keeping community.

Another thing.. they are talked about in the cold water/native section.. They are not a cold water fish so to speak. Once your water hits 50 degrees, they slow down.. they shouldn't be fed.. they go into hibernation for winter. They are also not native. Koi are somewhat like flower horns, but not hybrids.. it took many many years to breed colors into koi by the Japanese. Your chances of finding a "native" koi, is about 1 in a million around here.

There are many things that affect koi that most fish keepers never have to experience.. for example.. mouth rot- I can't tell you how much I've run into this.. it's not an easy fix.. It's not something that you can just salt either. And it could really mean life or death if it gets too far. There's also ulcers.. Koi ulcers are nothing like any tropical fish ulcer. Salt can help most of the time, but what happens when salt just isn't enough?

What about aeromonas, and the importance of running UV on your koi/pond set up?

What's the difference between feeding summer formula koi food, versus winter wheat germ formula?

What's the correlation between koi, and the University of Georgia?

We could even have an epic Food Vs Thread! I've tried almost every koi food out there, and I can attest to which foods are the best, and why. And I'm sure people want to know which foods are going to be the best, as food can ultimately make or break a show prize koi.

Patterns.. Asagi, Kohaku, Gin Rin, Utsuri...

Which patterns bred with which will make -insert pattern-?

Many people fail to realize that when you buy a koi- 5 years down the road it's NOT going to look the same. It could become even more astounding, or it could become the ugliest thing ever. -Oh, I like this all white koi...- 3 months late - that's not the koi I bought! Where did all the black spots come from?!- Koi are constantly changing and developing.

Which koi farms are bad-good-the best? (customer service, care, blood lines, growth etc..)

My koi is sick.. it needs an injection?! Say What?!!

These are just a few examples of things many koi keepers, or soon to be koi keepers would benefit from.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com