What's he asking for it? It's a nice one though.
I wouldn't pay anything over $60 for it at 6". That's just MO though
He's pretty, but remember, not everything uncommon is favorable. I wouldn't personally pay extra for a broken stripe.
I would tell him that it's a defect, and you aren't going to pay more for a defective fish. Tell him you will give him $50. It's 10 more than you want, and a little less than he's asking. If he takes it, good for you. If he doesn't, then you can know you didn't get taken advantage of over a stripe.To me its a Dat, not worth anything extra for a broken stripe or normal, and I could not see how anyone would charge extra for that, but someone is always out to try to make a VW bug a porsch or the other way around.
I would tell him that it's a defect, and you aren't going to pay more for a defective fish. Tell him you will give him $50. It's 10 more than you want, and a little less than he's asking. If he takes it, good for you. If he doesn't, then you can know you didn't get taken advantage of over a stripe.
I don't necessarily know that it's a defect, per se, but it sounds fancy. It certainly isn't worth more money. Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but I am to understand that a significant determining factor in the value of Dats, in addition to size, is their color, and the condition of their stripes. If the bands are dark, solid, uniform and unbroken, they are worth much more.