Grass Pickerel (how many feeders are too many?)

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

screaminleeman

Jack Dempsey
MFK Member
Nov 27, 2009
1,445
10
38
Westminster, MD
I want to make sure that I do not have my Pickerel grow out project demolished from overfeeding like I did to my Redfin pickerels.


Long story short, I quarantined 100 fathead minnows and majorly gut stuffed them for a month prior to getting my redfin pickerels. I was expecting the pickerel would likely be at least three times larger than they were when I got them. They were so small that I was certain that they could not eat the fattened roseys. I decided that I would put the pickerels in the tank after acclimatization while removing the minnows, and later replace with guppies. There were under a dozen fat roseys left when I released the Pickerels.

I lost every pickerel within second (Yes the roseys were way too big for the pickerel to eat, but everyone tried anyway and all choked on one!)

I bought 10 grass pickerel 1" - 2" several months ago. I have been carefully maintaining several tanks to keep similar sizes and have avoided predation with only one exception.

The all range from 5" to 7" at this point. I have only been feeding them an average of three roseys a piece per day, but it is extremely difficult as some are far more aggressive eaters than others (even at identical sizes). I have been afraid to place more feeders in their tanks than will be devoured in 30 seconds or so.

With baby Gar, there is no concern with keeping feeders in their tank 24/7. They eat what they want, and leave the rest for later.

I know they will kill themselves on feeders too large!

My question is: Will placing a large number of feeders in their tanks similar to the setup for baby gars work, or will they just non-stop keep eating themselves to death even with smaller feeders?
 
They will keep eating themselves to death, no matter what kind of feeders and even if they are full they will still attack the feeders. Had this problem with baby northern pike and muskellunges.
 
They will keep eating themselves to death, no matter what kind of feeders and even if they are full they will still attack the feeders. Had this problem with baby northern pike and muskellunges.

Thanks, I was kind of suspecting this, but figured I'd ask as the daily water changing on 4 quarantine totes is getting exhausting.

Fingers crossed (I am trying norfolk spot thin slices tonight to see if I can get them off live). They have not responded to any other cut fish and even live worms are way more miss than hit! :irked:
 
That's why I stopped keeping Esox species and crappies, they are super picky eaters that will taking ages to get them trained on pellets. They get starved to death easier than most species which I hate it so much.
 
I would feed a couple let thewm eat them and keep the guppies in a separate tank, then move the guppies over for feeding time.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com