Carpintis gender id? (vent pics included)

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Mb2435

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
May 17, 2022
6
2
3
36
Hi everyone, I recently got a new carpintis to pair with the one posted some time ago, Could someone tell me from these vent pics if this is a male or female? Thank you!

C29CB29B-949D-4004-A96E-5D57C370D694.jpeg

C7B4B054-DE20-4106-AD0D-E656BAF041BD.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
Hi everyone, I recently got a new carpintis to pair with the one posted some time ago, Could someone tell me from these vent pics if this is a male or female? Thank you!

View attachment 1497157

View attachment 1497158
Hi everyone, I recently got a new carpintis to pair with the one posted some time ago, Could someone tell me from these vent pics if this is a male or female? Thank you!

View attachment 1497157

View attachment 1497158

Female
The male will have a pointed looking tube.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mb2435
in most cases a side view pic will do, males are easily distinguished from females.
1655121230451.png
Compare the facial profile of the male above, with the female below
1655121291171.png
Even as small as 1" males are quite distinguishable from females (below)
1655121383392.png
And when they come into spawning dress, the females darken first
1655121447025.png
Also notice the more torpedo shape (above) compared to a male profile (below)
1655121506058.png
 
in most cases a side view pic will do, males are easily distinguished from females.
View attachment 1497263
Compare the facial profile of the male above, with the female below
View attachment 1497264
Even as small as 1" males are quite distinguishable from females (below)
View attachment 1497265
And when they come into spawning dress, the females darken first
View attachment 1497266
Also notice the more torpedo shape (above) compared to a male profile (below)
View attachment 1497267
Thank you. I couldn’t get a good sideview pic since the fish has been hiding. The vent pics were taken at the lfs. I’d be curious to hear your call based on the pics
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com