Phosphate removers in a canister filter?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

yamaracer5

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Sep 7, 2009
64
0
6
AZ
Can i put a phosphate remover such as phosban in a xp3 filter or do they only work in a reactor?
 
I know fluval makes a phosphate remover for canister filters, its under fluvals "lab series" filter media.
 
yamaracer5;3674832; said:
Can i put a phosphate remover such as phosban in a xp3 filter or do they only work in a reactor?

Bag it up, and put it in.
 
You can but it won't be as effective as running it through a reactor.
 
Well since no one is chimming in, I'm making a contribution to the database with some data.

Phosphates are one of the primary contributors to the growth of algae in an aquarium. The presence of the materialized form of any type of phosphate is known as ortho-phosphates. Ortho-phosphates are created by the breakdown of simple and complex organic phosphates and are major contributors to the growth of algae. High levels of phosphates not only lead to algae blooms, but have even been thought to have a much greater impact on algae growth than nitrates. Although phosphates generally arent considered detrimental to the health of your fish, levels higher than 1mg/L can lead to unsightly algae outbreaks.

Sources of Phosphates

Phosphates are introduced into your aquarium in many ways, even your tap water may contain phosphates. Other sources of phosphate include, but are not limited to, pH and KH buffers, carbon, fish food (and overfeeding) and even salt. Phosphates can even be generated within your aquarium through a heavy fish load, dead plant matter, undigested fish food in waste and even the dieing off of algae.

What To Do

In order to get a handle on phosphates, sources of phosphates need to be identified and eliminated (or reduced) and phosphates that are already present in your aquarium need to be removed.

Examine everything from fish food to salts and make sure that they contain little or no phosphates. If a product does contain phosphates, try to find a phosphate-free alternative. Make sure you are not over-feeding your fish or feeding them an inappropriate diet. Uneaten or undigested food is a source of phosphates.

Phosphates can be removed from your aquarium through good maintenance. Provided your tap water doesnt have extremely high levels of phosphates, frequent water changes are your best bet to reducing phosphates. Unless you have strong currents that keep debris from settling on your substrate, youll need to vacuum thoroughly to remove any waste and uneaten food. Frequent water changes should not only keep phosphate levels down, but your fish will also appreciate the clean water.

Another method of eliminating phosphates is through the use of phosphate-absorbing products. These are made by various aquarium product manufactures and can be added to your filter. Most of these require good water flow. When using them, make sure you read and follow all directions. Since some of these products generate a lot of heat when initially placed in water, make sure you wet them before adding them to your filter.
 
Try Chemipure elite in a canister filter. Have used it with great success and I disagree with the post saying its NOT as effective as a media reactor. I have seen all my tanks improve greatly with chemipure elite in eheim canisters for several years now.Also polyfiter is good but does not last as long but quickly with water changes can get the tank back on track, used it many times over the years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TUCCI
Try Chemipure elite in a canister filter. Have used it with great success and I disagree with the post saying its NOT as effective as a media reactor. I have seen all my tanks improve greatly with chemipure elite in eheim canisters for several years now.Also polyfiter is good but does not last as long but quickly with water changes can get the tank back on track, used it many times over the years.
As have I, it was one of the few names I recognized after I came back. The Polifilter was a product I used in Saltwater for a long time and it served me well. The canister of choice was the Ehiem 2217 as my come-back main filter.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com