Garnet is much better.
There are different quality grades of Garnet, the more expensive has deeper color than the cheaper.
Not only do I love 100% Garnet for it's effect on the fish, but I love how heavy it is, which in turn is good for my filter.
Yup I love it that it hasn't gone into my filters
Good luck Rod...
Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app