A. Compressiceps, or A. Calvus?

[M|L]

yup, the scales.

 

[SKAustin]

yup, the scales.

So am i to assume that your position remains that all of the fish in posts #1, #20, #21, #22, and #23 are all Calvus?

 

[M|L]

So am i to assume that your position remains that all of the fish in posts #1, #20, #21, #22, and #23 are all Calvus?

no.

but your fish is.

 

[SKAustin]

no.

but your fish is.

Um, ok
THOSE ARE MY FISH!

Sorry, didnt mean to yell. Tell me oh wise one, which are calvus and which are Compressiceps.

 

[M|L]

Tell me oh wise one, which are calvus and which are Compressiceps.

what do you mean? lol

I'm having an "Ash moment" here.

 

[SKAustin]

So am i to assume that your position remains that all of the fish in posts #1, #20, #21, #22, and #23 are all Calvus?

no.

but your fish is.

Tell me oh wise one, which are calvus and which are Compressiceps.

what do you mean? lol

I'm having an "Ash moment" here.

I mean, I have posted Photos on posts #1, #20, #21, #22, and #23.

You say that not all of the photos I have posted are Calvus, but my fish, assuming that you are speaking of the photo in post #1, is in fact a Calvus.

So my question is: Can you name for me what each fish is on posts #1, #20, #21, #22, and #23?

Like this:
#1, Compressiceps
#20, Compressiceps (top), Calvus (bottom)
#21, Calvus
#22, Compressiceps
#23, Compressiceps (forehead)

 

[M|L]

I never said, "not all of the photos you have posted are calvus".

I only said that your way of distingushing the two species by using the scale method may not work 100%.

 

[SKAustin]

So am i to assume that your position remains that all of the fish in posts #1, #20, #21, #22, and #23 are all Calvus?

no.

but your fish is.

Then what is that? Am I missing something?

 

[M|L]

ok, I was too lazy to look at the post numbers.

sorry.

post # 1, 20, 21 are calvus IMO.

 

[SKAustin]

22 and 23? any ideas?