A Game Of Thrones

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Woah sorry sumo but nothing I've said has happened in the future of the story line. Isn't the point of a discussion thread to discuss the show?

Yeah we have passed the point in the show where dany was supposed to have the visions, they didn't include that which I feel is detrimental to the story as a whole. None of the things I've said happened in the future part of the books as I've read. Always in the past in conjunction with the show. This is not confirmed in any way about jon being half targ half stark at any point its a random theory, and a very interesting one at that that could be true. Only thing said about his mother in the show is by Ned who called her wylla. The way Ned acts in that scene he is obviously being very evasive to Robert, why should he be so evasive so many years later with his best friend if his mother was some random?

Also in the books the archer of the Brotherhood says to Arya while she's a captive that him and Jon were milk-brothers by a nurse named.... Wylla. Which is another thing I wish was included in the show. It just sucks the show watchers don't get all the little easter eggs that allude to potential plot twists I feel like that's one of the best part of the Game.

Jon snow is a mystery to us, he is presented as a mystery by his own claimed father. You are supposed to contemplate his origins, show or book. My speculations were simply contemplations on his origins. There are several other theories that have there own supportive plot elements that point elsewhere. I just like that one the most lol

Sent from my XT1080 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
robmcd said:
None that I have heard of yet. It sucks because as soon as it comes out, I will be the guy who pays 40$ the first day it comes out and tear through it in a week...
Click to expand...

I thought it was suppose to come out the week this season started but never bothered to verify anything as it came up in a casual conversation with an avid reader in the family. If you read it that fast, just hang out and read it at your local book store lol.


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
BuffaloPolypteridae said:
Woah sorry sumo but nothing I've said has happened in the future of the story line. Isn't the point of a discussion thread to discuss the show?

Yeah we have passed the point in the show where dany was supposed to have the visions, they didn't include that which I feel is detrimental to the story as a whole. None of the things I've said happened in the future part of the books as I've read. Always in the past in conjunction with the show. This is not confirmed in any way about jon being half targ half stark at any point its a random theory, and a very interesting one at that that could be true. Only thing said about his mother in the show is by Ned who called her wylla. The way Ned acts in that scene he is obviously being very evasive to Robert, why should he be so evasive so many years later with his best friend if his mother was some random?

Also in the books the archer of the Brotherhood says to Arya while she's a captive that him and Jon were milk-brothers by a nurse named.... Wylla. Which is another thing I wish was included in the show. It just sucks the show watchers don't get all the little easter eggs that allude to potential plot twists I feel like that's one of the best part of the Game.

Jon snow is a mystery to us, he is presented as a mystery by his own claimed father. You are supposed to contemplate his origins, show or book. My speculations were simply contemplations on his origins. There are several other theories that have there own supportive plot elements that point elsewhere. I just like that one the most lol

Sent from my XT1080 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
Click to expand...


I know you don't mean to, and it's probably harder to see what you're doing since you are reading the books and watching the show.

but by revealing info that happened in the book that did not happen in the show is giving away things I would rather now know.

like Dany's visions. to me that's a spoiler. since you're reading the books, it's not a spoiler to you. but I would rather not know that since the show left that out. now in the future if dany does somehow end up being linked to jon snow, that would've blown my mind. now that you revealed it, it spoils it for me

as well as what you mentioned about what the archer said to arya.

I don't know, maybe it's just me but i'd rather not know things about the book that the show chose to leave out. maybe someone else can chime in who doesn't read the books. am I the only one feeling this way?
 
SumoNinja said:
I know you don't mean to, and it's probably harder to see what you're doing since you are reading the books and watching the show.

but by revealing info that happened in the book that did not happen in the show is giving away things I would rather now know.

like Dany's visions. to me that's a spoiler. since you're reading the books, it's not a spoiler to you. but I would rather not know that since the show left that out. now in the future if dany does somehow end up being linked to jon snow, that would've blown my mind. now that you revealed it, it spoils it for me

as well as what you mentioned about what the archer said to arya.

I don't know, maybe it's just me but i'd rather not know things about the book that the show chose to leave out. maybe someone else can chime in who doesn't read the books. am I the only one feeling this way?
Click to expand...

Nope, you are dead on 1000%. :thumbsup:

Especially since I'll read the books once the series is done.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
MonsterFishKeepers.com
Top Bottom