I'd have to see it to be sure but it sounds like you've got calcium deposits (wich won't come off with a razor or acetone). I don't know it that's what you've got but try putting some vinegar on it. Leave it on for 10 minutes and wipe off. Just a possibility.
the tank never leaked in the first place but the old silicone looked questionable so i redid it anyways. once again thanks to everyone who has answered my multiple questions on tank sealing.





.