acrylic vs. glass

[Hadrian]

so this isn't stricktly a crenicichla topic..and the thread exists elsewhere on MFK...but I trust my pike amigos most of all, so what do you guys think about glass vs acrylic tanks?

 

[rallysman]

This is an argument that will never end. Both will get the job done, but it all comes down to personal preference. Get what you like better

 

[Polypterus Senegalus]

dosnt make a difference. half or my tanks are second hand and beat beyond repair. i dont care what they are made of or what they look like. just as long as i can see through them and put fish in them. get whatever looks better to you. acrylic can be VERY PRICEY! glass works just fine!

 

[ShadowStryder]

This is an argument that will never end. Both will get the job done, but it all comes down to personal preference. Get what you like better

+1
As long as it hold water and I can put fish in them. I have 2 glass 55's that are my first two tanks I bought in 1986. Still hold water and pretty scratched up but I wouldn't retire them for anything.

 

[Peanut_Power]

Got both, love them both. Acrylic is lighter, but definately not cheaper depending on where you go. The problem with scratches is another thing to think about. Glass rocks, but has its downsides too. Reallly, its all up to you and your wallet man. Do what suites you best, as was stated several times!

 

[sicxspeed]

I think that glass is clearer in the long run, but for me it is not an option because i live on the 2nd floor and try to keep the weight down as much as possible, so Acrylic it is for me, huge weight savings......

 

[rallysman]

I think that glass is clearer in the long run, but for me it is not an option because i live on the 2nd floor and try to keep the weight down as much as possible, so Acrylic it is for me, huge weight savings......

If the weight difference of the tank itself is enough to make it unsafe, you have no business even standing next to the tank. The weight only matters when you're moving it.

 

[Peanut_Power]

If the weight difference of the tank itself is enough to make it unsafe, you have no business even standing next to the tank. The weight only matters when you're moving it.

Or if the floors were uneven. Any change in pressure COULD possibly crack the tank, not good.

In the larger tankz, say 300+...then yeah it could make a big difference though!

 

[rallysman]

Or if the floors were uneven. Any change in pressure COULD possibly crack the tank, not good.

In the larger tankz, say 300+...then yeah it could make a big difference though!

Keep in mind that an uneven stand/floor will have more impact on an acrylic tank. There is no give in the seams, so they'll just POP. (Glass will too, but it's a bit more forgiving)

I would love to trade my 300g acrylic for a glass one.

 

[sicxspeed]

If the weight difference of the tank itself is enough to make it unsafe, you have no business even standing next to the tank. The weight only matters when you're moving it.

I said "Try to keep the weight down as much as possible". I choose to go this route on my own based on the fact that im on the second floor, what others do and what others opinions are on the situation is just that, their opinion.

Oh, and yes, I agree, moving the tanks, acrylic is a log easier. FYI, i've done both and choose acrylic over glass. There can be a several hundred pound difference in acrylic and glass the same size depending on the size of the tank. Im no contractor but understand how to place a tank on the 2nd floor. Not that i'm arguing with you Rally, I know what you mean and it makes sense, I see where your coming from, but mentally, it gives me more peace of mind.