Activated Carbon....

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Peanut_Power

Running From The Hammer...
MFK Member
Jul 6, 2005
15,041
35
36
BannedVille
www.monsterfishkeepers.com
Aight, so I haven't had activated carbon in my tankz for almost 4 months now cuz I have to put it in the filter myself...and i was lazy. However, just this week i got a large half gal. carton of Activated Filter Carbon, 16 oz. i think and put it into my 75 and 125gal tankz. I put it into some pantyhose that was holding some peat moss in the filters, rinsed it, and then put it back in the filter. I'm hopin I will see a difference in the water clarity and the colors of the fish.

I'm curious about what all you guys think. How many people here actually use Activated Filter Carbon in their filters/tankz? Explain why you do or why you don't use it. Thankz! Jer
 
Don't use it, ever ;)

Get's exhausted to fast, especially if you do alot of water changes. Its really cheap to produce, and the aquarium industry has been making money off of it for years. I have talked to a few other people about it, and they seem to think the same. Some people swear by it.. I think it's over-rated.

Use Chemi-pure instead, primarly when new fish are arriving.
 
I don't use it. It's like a cover up for a more serious problem. There shouldn't be a need for carbon, imo.
 
Found a good article on the activated carbon.....hope this will help.....

Just what is activated carbon? What is the best kind to buy? How long does it last? Should I use it in my aquarium? These are some of the questions I will attempt to answer.
Activated carbon is carbon that has been treated with oxygen in order to open up millions of tiny pores between the carbon atoms. It can have anywhere from 300 to 2,000 square meters of surface area per gram, or 116 to 750 square feet per ounce. Activated carbon absorbs various substances, from gases and liquids. By absorb, I mean attaching to the pores by chemical reaction. When certain chemicals pass next to the carbon surface, they attach to that surface and are trapped.
Carbon can be made from animal, mineral, or plant-based materials such as bituminous coal, lignite coal, various woods, coconut shells, peat, and animal bones. The types of activated carbon include granular, pelletized, and powdered. It can be acid washed or non-acid washed.
Activated carbons are also used in liquid, gas, and air filtering. Many of the home water-filtering systems use activated carbon. It is an effective means of removing dissolved organic compounds (DOC's) from the aquarium. Activated carbons made from bituminous coal are the most effective for aquarium use. They contain a wide range of pore sizes, enabling it to remove a wide range of organic pollutants. Coconut-shell carbon, on the other hand, has a large surface area but very small pores and many of the organic compounds are too large to fit. This type of carbon is primarily designed for gas filtering. Lignite coal produces carbons with the opposite problem. Their pores are large enough for common organic molecules but has a reduced total surface area. It can be used, but you will need a lot more carbon to remove the same amount of organic material than carbon made from bituminous coal.

The use of activated carbon can increase phosphate levels in the aquarium. These increased levels can lead to algae growth. All carbons are organic in source, therefore rich in phosphates. Acid-washed carbons will leach less phosphate than others and are usually more expensive, since they have had much of their ash and phosphate washed out. Ash is important because it is responsible for "pH shock". Some carbons can increase pH to over 10 in a very short time. An acid-washed carbon will barely increase pH to 7 over several days. Carbons that do not alter pH are usually the same carbons that will not leach much phosphate.
All carbons should be rinsed well before being placed in the filter system. A yellowish tint in your water can indicate the need for carbon replacement. It can lose a large percentage of its effectiveness in two to four weeks. Organic materials and bacterial slime coat the surface blocking access to the inner pores. Rinsing the carbon between changes can extend its useful life.
As a general rule of thumb, it is better to use less carbon and change it more often. The amount I hear most often is roughly 100 ml per 30 gallons with monthly changes. Another general rule is, the lighter the weight of the carbon for a given volume, the better.
When treating fish with medications, the carbon should be removed from the filter. After treatment, the carbon can be put back in to help remove the medications although water changes should be performed in addition. I would recommend changing the carbon a week to two weeks after you have used it to remove medications.
The use of activated carbon with live plants is greatly debated. Generally, planted-tank aquarists do not use activated carbon for fear of losing trace elements needed by the plants.
 
Never used it, never needed to.

All I have is bio and mech filtration and my water is never anything less than pristine.

Why? Because most water isn't so bad in quality that it needs carbon to filter it. Also, the longevity of carbon is limited, and it can wreck any medication put into the tank.
 
I use it only to remove medicine... have nothing against it tho, cos i have seen people using it 24/7 and their aquarium water is very clear and the fishes look healthy. I think if u change it regularly there shouldnt be a problem of leeching.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com