African Cichlids Or American Cichlids????

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
I prefer Americans because they are like puppies. Meaning they are very personable and have the potential to become quite large. They greet you upon arriving to the tank. My Umbee and Red Devil (Midevil) recognizes me and the food container. They are like dogs wagging their tails. When I kept Africans they only interacted when it was feeding time. They always had territorial disputes and pretty much ignored me.

True, if you refer to African Great Lake cichlids as don't know of any that interact with the owner,not even Frontosa. But African cichlids from Madagasca and West Africa behave more like Americans and interact strongly with the owner. Have you ever kept Polleni or Hemichromis Elongatus? They behave like Midas.
 
i love my five star generals (hemichromis elongatus) i have a group of six, some videos of them in my youtube channel below... some africans are just like americans in their attitude, paratilapia polleni, tilapia buttikoferi, tilapia mossambicus, red jewels, any of the jewels to be fair...
i had a tank plan for a massive group of red jewels in a tank around 200g with one butti grown with them so he doesnt see them as food hopefully... nice 12 inch plus butti and a nice big group of super red jewels would look great in a biotope setup.
 
True, if you refer to African Great Lake cichlids as don't know of any that interact with the owner,not even Frontosa. But African cichlids from Madagasca and West Africa behave more like Americans and interact strongly with the owner. Have you ever kept Polleni or Hemichromis Elongatus? They behave like Midas.

No I haven’t had the pleasure I might research them. Do you have any video on YouTube?
 
[video=youtube;tNjXgfpdVxw]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tNjXgfpdVxw[/video]

my group, mini monsters!-)
 
Interesting! I have never seen red jewels mixed in with 5 Star Jewels and wonder how long the red jewels can hold as the 5 star can hit 10 inch.

BTW, noone keeps Mbuna or Hap as a solitary pet, always in a group. So you never know if they will interact with the owner as they are too busy watching one another.
 
.................

BTW, noone keeps Mbuna or Hap as a solitary pet, always in a group. So you never know if they will interact with the owner as they are too busy watching one another.
A few years ago, purely ignorant, we got 2 baby mbuna from my lfs for an empty 20G. One is a male kenyi, & the other resembles a female, so you can imagine how quickly the violence unfolded. kenyi=devil fish. the poor little blue guy was gonna get killed, so I put a divider in "until we decided Who was Going Back to store".
They began sparring through the divider & both love it so much that we kept both fish.
The kenyi is named Fin Laden for terrorizing & attacking EVERYthing, including my hands. BUT he has eventually developed the most personality & YES: consistent interaction through the glass of all our fish. he gets better with time. Now he wags, jumps & bumps glass toward my husband. his head above water for food is the least of his character.
He definitely recognizes and distinguishes between us, behaving differently for each, as well as our 3 yr old grandson :-/ who we permit feeding some pellets.
He isn't like that with strangers. when my visiting brother approached, he hid in his cave for the first time in ages. would not eat with him standing nearby.
Fin Laden is a very active, personable fish. highly interactive toward family. and he is sharper than most. perhaps without the normally large numbers of other fish to "keep an eye on" and concentrate on, they have more brainpower left to focus on out-of-tank inhabitants. (that is my personal theory)
? If I could only keep one small tank, it'd be his. and when he dies we'll get another. we did hate him at first, though!
BTW, little Bluey, the other mbuna is also interactive. not aggressive or glass banger: a broken man. lol. he hurls water out of tank at most feedings though, sometimes quite a distance.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com